ROE (Net Income) versus ROE-CI (Comprehensive Income): A Multidimensional Analysis of a Time-Honoured Performance Metric
Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Central European Economic Journal
- Vol. 13 (60) , 192-207
Abstract
Business performance is key for all stakeholders. Return on equity (ROE) measures how effectively resources generate profits and indicates both the profitability and managerial efficiency. The traditional ROE, based only on net income, is sensitive to accounting policy (AP) choices and valuation models under IAS/IFRS. Since valuation effects may be recognised either in profit or loss or in other comprehensive income (OCI), ROE can be distorted. This problem has intensified with the introduction of IFRS 9 (2018) and during recent crises, when incentives for earnings management increased. The purpose of this study is to address two research questions: Does the traditional ROE adequately reflect the financial performance efficiency (Q1), and does the use of traditional ROE versus return on equity-comprehensive income (ROE-CI) lead to significant differences in the assessment (Q2)? The methodological triad juxtaposes academic comparative analysis, AI Chat GPT suggestions, and an empirical case study regarding 10 banks listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange and their financial statements for 2017–2024, comparing ROE, ROE-CI, and the AP ratio to assess the impact of OCI on performance. The academic comparison and AI suggestions are not conclusive; the case study shows that banks increasingly use OCI to recognise valuation effects, creating discrepancies between ROE and ROE-CI. Pioneeringly, it is suggested that the proposed AP ratio (OCI/P) detects distortions and indicates when ROE-CI should be applied to reflect profitability.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Enhancing equity return forecasting through oil price fluctuations: An analysis of economic constraints and predictive strategiesEnergy Strategy Reviews, 2026
- Digital business model innovation, operational efficiency, and corporate financial performanceFinance Research Letters, 2025
- Weak capital, weak provisions—Credit risk provisioning under IFRS 9Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2025
- Disclosure policy for relative performance indicators under product market competitionJournal of Accounting and Public Policy, 2025
- Private equity buyout pricing, returns, and portfolio firm performance across UK regionsThe British Accounting Review, 2025
- Firm connection and equity return predictability – Graph-based machine learning methodsThe British Accounting Review, 2024
- Fair value accounting and value relevance of equity book value and net income for European financial firms during the crisisJournal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, 2020
- Influence of some financial indicators on return on equity ratio in the Romanian energy sector - A competitive approach using a DuPont-based analysisEnergy, 2019
- The persistence of earnings and cash flows and the role of special items: Implications for the accrual anomalyReview of Accounting Studies, 2006
- Do investors overvalue firms with bloated balance sheets?Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2004