Frontier Regulation of Electricity Distribution: Why Economists are Wrong and Engineers are Only Half Right
Preprint
- 20 April 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Frontier benchmarking is central to incentive regulation in electricity distribution. Yet it is typically implemented using nonparametric cost frontiers that impose economic assumptions, such as convexity, thereby abstracting away from sophisticated nonlinear alternating-current power-flow models. This paper shows that, although physically faithful, mathematically accurate specifications of power-flow systems are difficult to deploy for constructing regulatory cost frontiers at scale, while the adoption of nonparametric frontiers can itself give rise to structural misspecifications. We derive a production possibility set and an associated cost function from a stylised power-flow model and compare the resulting engineering benchmark with convex and nonconvex nonparametric estimators. We find that convexification can generate systematic deviations from the engineering cost frontier, whereas nonconvex counterparts provide substantially closer approximations. Evidence from Finnish and Iranian electricity distributors points in the same direction: nonconvex cost frontiers fit the data better and imply materially different efficiency assessments. In this sense, while economists can be wrong in acritically adopting a convex paradigm, engineering models, despite not directly delivering regulatory objects, can be accurately approximated by nonconvex cost frontiers.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Testing the convexity hypothesis in nonparametric cost functionsEconomics Letters, 2025
- The Effects of Vertical Separation and Competition: Evidence from US Electric Utility RestructuringReview of Industrial Organization, 2024
- Application of Production Economics in the Electricity Distribution Sector2022
- Cost functions are nonconvex in the outputs when the technology is nonconvex: convexification is not harmlessAnnals of Operations Research, 2021
- Optimal scale sizes in input–output allocative data envelopment analysis modelsAnnals of Operations Research, 2019
- Maximum entropy: a stochastic frontier approach for electricity distribution regulationJournal of Regulatory Economics, 2019
- Valuation and pricing of electricity delivery contracts: the producer’s viewAnnals of Operations Research, 2018
- Acceleration strategies of Benders decomposition for the security constraints power system expansion planningAnnals of Operations Research, 2015
- An Introduction to CNLS and StoNED Methods for Efficiency Analysis: Economic Insights and Computational Aspects2015
- Non-convex aggregate technology and optimal economic growthEconomic Theory, 2008