Social value judgments in healthcare: a philosophical critique
Authors:
- Benedict RumboldBRBenedict Rumbold
- Ruth FadenRFRuth Faden
- 15 June 2012
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Health Organization and Management
- Vol. 26 (3) , 317-330
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to consider some of the philosophical and bioethical issues raised by the creation of the draft social values framework developed to facilitate data collection and country‐specific presentations at the inaugural workshop on “Social values and health priority setting” held in February 2011.Design/methodology/approach: Conceptual analysis is used to analyse the term “social values”, as employed in the framework, and its relationship to related ideas such as moral values. The structure of the framework (process and content values) is considered in light of current debate in philosophy and bioethics about the political and moral aims served by these kinds of values, and the extent to which they are either suited to, or sufficient for, the policy context.Findings: There is much to be gained by engaging with the arguments presented in the philosophical literature in order to further refine the framework. The framework should remain neutral in respect of the importance of procedural values in different contexts and should be as inclusive as possible in respect of the principles it includes. Further development would be best served by taking a multidisciplinary approach. The framework could provide a valuable space in which future debates about procedural/substantive values can be considered.Originality/value: The paper brings philosophical and bioethics perspectives to bear on a new framework proposed for the analysis of social values in health priority setting. It identifies how such a practical, policy‐focused framework might be informed by engagement with deeper, and often unresolved, questions or principle around resource allocation in health.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Complete Lives in the BalanceThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2010
- Public participation in health care priority setting: A scoping reviewHealth Policy, 2009
- Justice and procedure: how does “accountability for reasonableness” result in fair limit-setting decisions?Journal of Medical Ethics, 2008
- Should the capability approach be applied in Health Economics?Health Economics, 2008
- BEYOND ACCOUNTABILITY FOR REASONABLENESSBioethics, 2008
- Priority setting in health care: Lessons from the experiences of eight countriesInternational Journal for Equity in Health, 2008
- QALYs and capabilities: a response to AnandHealth Economics, 2005
- QALYs and capabilities: a comment on CooksonHealth Economics, 2005
- Capabilities and healthJournal of Medical Ethics, 2005
- Who should get the kidney machine?Journal of Medical Ethics, 1992