Creating Clear and Informative Image-based Figures for Scientific Publications
Authors:
- Helena JamborHJHelena Jambor
- Alberto AntoniettiAAAlberto Antonietti
- Bradly J AliceaBABradly J Alicea
- Tracy Lynn AudisioTATracy Lynn Audisio
- Susann AuerSASusann Auer
- Vivek BhardwajVBVivek Bhardwaj
- Steven James BurgessSBSteven James Burgess
- Iuliia FerlingIFIuliia Ferling
- Małgorzata Anna GazdaMGMałgorzata Anna Gazda
- Luke H. HoeppnerLHLuke H. Hoeppner
- Vinodh IlangovanVIVinodh Ilangovan
- Hung LoHLHung Lo
Preprint
Abstract
Scientists routinely use images to display data. Readers often examine figures first; therefore, it is important that figures are accessible to a broad audience. Many resources discuss fraudulent image manipulation and technical specifications for image acquisition; however, data on the legibility and interpretability of images are scarce. We systematically examined these factors in non-blot images published in the top 15 journals in three fields; plant sciences, cell biology and physiology (n=580 papers). Common problems included missing scale bars, misplaced or poorly marked insets, images or labels that were not accessible to colorblind readers, and insufficient explanations of colors, labels, annotations, or the species and tissue or object depicted in the image. Papers that met all good practice criteria examined for all image-based figures were uncommon (physiology 16%, cell biology 12%, plant sciences 2%). We present detailed descriptions and visual examples to help scientists avoid common pitfalls when publishing images. Our recommendations address image magnification, scale information, insets, annotation, and color and may encourage discussion about quality standards for bioimage publishing.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: PLOS Biology, 19 (3), e3001161.
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- How to (seriously) read a scientific paper2021
- Training early career researchers to use meta-research to improve science: A participant-guided “learn by doing” approachPLOS Biology, 2021
- Imaging methods are vastly underreported in biomedical researcheLife, 2020
- Variability in the analysis of a single neuroimaging dataset by many teamsNature, 2020
- Neuroimaging results altered by varying analysis pipelinesNature, 2020
- SourceData: a semantic platform for curating and searching figuresNature Methods, 2017
- Assessing phototoxicity in live fluorescence imagingNature Methods, 2017
- Viziometrics: Analyzing Visual Information in the Scientific LiteratureIEEE Transactions on Big Data, 2017
- The Prevalence of Inappropriate Image Duplication in Biomedical Research PublicationsmBio, 2016
- A Brief Guide to Designing Effective Figures for the Scientific PaperAdvanced Materials, 2011