Non-stationarity in population parameters requires careful interpretation of equilibrium reference points
Open Access
- 1 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (10)
Abstract
A key reference point in fisheries management is the limit reference point (LRP), which represents a biomass threshold below which serious harm to the fish population is believed to occur. Reference points are often based on equilibrium quantities such as unfished spawning biomass ($SB_0$) or spawning biomass at maximum sustainable yield ($SB_{\rm {MSY}}$), which are calculated using parameters that are assumed constant over time. When equilibrium assumptions are not met within a stock assessment (e.g., when natural mortality (M) is changing over time), there is a question of how to define reference points, especially when changes in productivity parameters cause reference points to change in scale. In this study, we develop simulation models based on recent stock assessments for three Pacific herring (Clupea pallasii) stocks for which M is estimated to have increased on average over the past 50 years. We explore relationships between M, $SB_0$ and stock-recruit parameters under typical assumptions used in stock assessments. We pose two questions: (1) Are equilibrium-based reference points meaningful for Pacific herring stocks when productivity is changing rapidly? and (2) How do different derivations of the LRP impact perceptions of stock status and the relationship of the LRP to serious harm thresholds? We show that when productivity is changing rapidly, the calculation of $SB_0$ using typical analytical approaches can violate equilibrium assumptions. Moreover, when M is increasing, the strong negative relationship between M and $SB_0$ means that LRPs based on dynamic recent values of M can be substantially lower than LRPs based on historical or long-term average values M. Allowing LRP thresholds to decrease with increasing M results in more optimistic assessments of stock status and potentially allows LRPs to drop to levels below serious harm thresholds. We invite practitioners to take a more thoughtful approach to the question of whether LRPs should be lowered in the presence of increasing natural mortality.
Keywords
Funding Information
- Government of Canada (4171361)
This publication has 78 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quantifying ecosystem responses to environmental and human pressures in the marine ecosystem off the west coast of Vancouver IslandEcological Indicators, 2021
- Spatial variation in exploited metapopulations obscures risk of collapseEcological Applications, 2019
- How much evidence is required for acceptance of productivity regime shifts in fish stock assessments: Are we letting managers off the hook?Fisheries Research, 2015
- Modelling the effects of density-dependent mortality in juvenile red snapper caught as bycatch in Gulf of Mexico shrimp fisheries: Implications for managementFisheries Research, 2013
- Management implications of including a climate-induced recruitment shift in the stock assessment for jackass morwong (Nemadactylus macropterus) in south-eastern AustraliaFisheries Research, 2013
- The impact of climate change on the performance of rebuilding strategies for overfished groundfish species of the U.S. west coastFisheries Research, 2011
- Evaluating the estimation of fishery management reference points in a variable environmentFisheries Research, 2009
- In search of thresholds for recruitment overfishingICES Journal of Marine Science, 1994
- Quantitative Fisheries Stock Assessment1992
- Optimal fishery policy for size-specific, density-dependent population modelsJournal of Mathematical Biology, 1981