Theory and method reconsidered: a Marxist analysis of Trespass law

Author:
  • PVPeter Vincent-Jones
    Peter Vincent-Jones

Abstract
Law governing agents' possession of and separation from land is given as an object of study by struggles over land possession in the conjuncture involving squatting, factory occupations, and public protests and gatherings infringing private property rights. Marx's mature method, incorporating a concrete → abstract → concrete logical trajectory, can be adapted and developed in relation to law so as to enable the successful concrete analysis of this object. The point of departure is the simplest and most irreducible expression of Trespass in concrete social practice: the right to exclude the world from interference with possession of land. The concrete particular is analyzed through abstraction, which further accompanies the movement from simple to ever more complex aspects of the object until the concrete totality of law securing the conditions of land occupation and conrol in the capitalist formation is completely revealed and explained. The basic social function of Trespass law, in its embodiment of exclusive private property right, is to guarantee the conditions of exclusive possession and control under capitalism; this area of law ultimately providing the means by which the legal and socio-economic crisis of the 1970s could be resolved to the advantage of the greater possessors, at the expense of lesser possessory inteests.