ConDiffFuzz: Dependency-Aware Consistency Checking for Differential Fuzzing of Industrial Control Protocol Implementations
Open Access
- 22 March 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Electronics
- Vol. 15 (6) , 1324
Abstract
Consistency checking across independently developed implementations of the same industrial control protocol provides an effective signal for defect discovery because an implementation whose response deviates from the majority under identical inputs is more likely to contain faults or robustness issues. However, existing consistency checking methods remain difficult to apply to complex stateful protocols in practice, since sequence dependencies can cause error propagation, large test suites incur high execution cost across multiple implementations, and inconsistent outputs are costly to triage. This paper proposes ConDiffFuzz, a dependency-aware and dynamically adjusted hierarchical consistency checking method for industrial control protocol implementations. ConDiffFuzz analyzes dependencies among check sequences to optimize execution order and dynamically prunes and regenerates dependent sequences after failures to mitigate inconsistency error propagation. The checking process derives implementation-specific finite state machines and inconsistency records, which further support focused differential fuzzing, parallel execution across multiple implementations, and log-based anomaly triage. Experiments on five Modbus over Modbus/TCP implementations show that ConDiffFuzz achieves a test case acceptance rate of 86.00%, increases average path coverage to 74.46%, improves the average number of triggered anomalies by 12.28%, and reduces the false-positive rate by 20.94% compared with four representative baseline fuzzers (SPIKE, BooFuzz, PeachFuzzer, and Kitty).Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- QUIC-Fuzz: An Effective Greybox Fuzzer For The QUIC Protocol2025
- CSFuzzer: A grey-box fuzzer for network protocol using context-aware state feedbackComputers & Security, 2025
- Learning single and compound-protocol automata and checking behavioral equivalencesInternational Journal on Software Tools for Technology Transfer, 2025
- A survey on fuzz testing technologies for industrial control protocolsJournal of Network and Computer Applications, 2024
- On the (in)efficiency of fuzzing network protocolsAnnals of Telecommunications, 2024
- NCMFuzzer: Using non-critical field mutation and test case combination to improve the efficiency of ICS protocol fuzzingComputers & Security, 2024
- Cryptographic protocol conformance testing based on domain-specific state machineJournal of Computer Virology and Hacking Techniques, 2023
- Machine learning in industrial control system (ICS) security: current landscape, opportunities and challengesJournal of Intelligent Information Systems, 2022
- Using memory propagation tree to improve performance of protocol fuzzer when testing ICSComputers & Security, 2019
- A dynamic protocol conformance test methodJournal of Systems and Software, 2003