Jumping on the Bandwagon: Comparing the Efficacy of Chlorhexidine Versus Povidone-Iodine Preoperative Skin Antiseptic in Preventing Surgical Site Infections Following Pediatric Orthopaedic Surgery
- 21 September 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics
- Vol. 42 (1) , e39-e44
Abstract
Background: Adult literature has demonstrated chlorhexidine (CH) superiority at preventing surgical-site infections when compared with povidone-iodine (P-I). The purpose of this study is to compare the rate of postoperative infections after preoperative skin cleansing with either CH or P-I in pediatric orthopaedic surgery in an effort to identify superiority. Methods: We retrospectively identified all patients (18 y and below) that underwent orthopaedic surgery at our institution in 2015, when P-I was the preoperative skin antisepsis of choice, and in 2018, when a change in protocol resulted in more frequent use of CH. Open fractures, infections, neuromuscular, and tumor surgeries were excluded. Orthopaedic surgeries were classified according to their subspecialty (sports-related/upper extremity, hip and lower extremity, trauma-related, or spine procedure). A 1:1 propensity score matching was conducted within each procedure group on the basis of age, sex, and year using nearest-neighbor matching. Spine procedures could not be matched and were subsequently excluded from analyses. Results: Propensity score matching matched 1416 CH cases with 1416 P-I controls. The infection rate for CH was 19 infections per 1000 cases (27/1416; 1.9%) compared with an infection rate of 11 infections per 1000 cases (16/1416; 1.1%) for P-I subjects. No difference was detected in infection rate across preoperative skin antisepsis groups (P=0.12). Moreover, it was found that CH and P-I resulted in significantly equivalent infection rates to within ±1.5% (P=0.004). When stratified by procedure type, CH used in sports/upper extremity procedures resulted in 29 more infections per 1000 cases compared with P-I use (16/450; 3/450; P=0.005). No difference was detected in infection rate across CH and P-I skin antisepsis groups in lower extremity procedures (9/792; 8/792; P=1.00) or in trauma-related procedures (3/174; 4/174; P=1.00). Conclusions: CH and P-I are both protective against postoperative infections after sports/upper extremity, lower extremity, and trauma-related pediatric orthopaedic procedures. P-I may provide improved protection over CH as a preoperative skin antisepsis in upper extremity and sports-related procedures. Level of Evidence: Level III—comparative cohort.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Epidemiology of Pediatric Surgical Admissions in US ChildrenJournal of Neurosurgical Anesthesiology, 2012
- Minimizing Wound Contamination in a ‘Clean’ Surgery: Comparison of Chlorhexidine-Ethanol and Povidone-IodineChemotherapy, 2010
- Chlorhexidine–Alcohol versus Povidone–Iodine for Surgical-Site AntisepsisNew England Journal of Medicine, 2010
- Efficacy of Surgical Preparation Solutions in Shoulder SurgeryJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2009
- Chlorhexidine Provides Superior Skin Decontamination in Foot and Ankle SurgeryClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 2005
- A Randomized Trial Comparing Povidone-Iodine to a Chlorhexidine Gluconate-Impregnated Dressing for Prevention of Central Venous Catheter Infections in NeonatesPediatrics, 2001
- Chlorhexidine versus Povidone Iodine in Preventing Colonization of Continuous Epidural Catheters in ChildrenAnesthesiology, 2001
- Pediatric Wound InfectionsAnnals of Surgery, 1998
- Wound infection in pediatric surgery: A study in 1,094 neonatesJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 1993
- Wound infection in a children's hospitalBritish Journal of Surgery, 1976