When the Client Is a Former Auditor: Auditees' Expert Knowledge and Social Capital as Threats to Staff Auditors' Operational Independence
- 15 December 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 37 (3) , 1333-1369
Abstract
Auditees can play an active role in influencing staff auditors' professional judgment and skepticism. Yet, although it constitutes one of the main threats to auditor independence, very little is known about the means and extent of auditees' power during the audit engagement. To address this knowledge gap, our study focuses on a specific category of auditees, namely, auditees who have worked as auditors in large accounting firms. We interviewed 36 of these auditees and triangulated our findings with 11 interviews conducted with auditors. At the theoretical level, we conceptualize auditees' influence over auditors as intentional and active through the notion of “social power.” Overall, our analysis shows that the efficacy of auditees' power during the engagement materializes through the mobilization of two main power resources developed during their time at the firms: (i) expert knowledge of auditing techniques and (ii) social capital. On the one hand, relying on their cognitive authority, auditees' employ three different power strategies to constrain staff auditors' operational independence: stage‐setting, teaching, and questioning. On the other hand, auditees' social capital can support the use of two additional strategies: attracting and monitoring. Our triangulation analysis confirms our findings and suggests that auditors may be aware of the threats to independence that auditee expertise and social capital pose. By focusing on auditees' agentic capabilities—that is, individuals' capabilities to consciously exert influence over the course of events—we reinterpret the pressures exerted by clients on auditors as the product of strategic actions and discuss substantive consequences for independence risk.Keywords
This publication has 109 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hiring as Cultural MatchingAmerican Sociological Review, 2012
- The Effect of the Social Mismatch between Staff Auditors and Client Management on the Collection of Audit EvidenceThe Accounting Review, 2012
- An Examination of the Layers of Workplace Influences in Ethical Judgments: Whistleblowing Likelihood and Perseverance in Public AccountingJournal of Business Ethics, 2009
- The organizational context of professionalism in accountingAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2009
- A comparison of auditor and client initial negotiation positions and tacticsAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2007
- How Subgroup Interests and Reputations Moderate the Effect of Organizational Identification on CooperationJournal of Management, 2004
- Reinventing auditing, redefining consulting and independenceEuropean Accounting Review, 1998
- On being a professional in a “Big Six” firmAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1998
- Identification of accounting firm alumni with their former firm: Antecedents and outcomesAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1997
- Getting comfortable with the numbers: Auditing and the micro-production of macro-orderAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1993