Why You Don’t Have to Choose between Accuracy and Human Officiating (But You Might Want to Anyway)
Open Access
- 14 June 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 4 (2) , 33
Abstract
Debates about the role of technology in sports officiating assume that technology would, ceteris paribus, improve accuracy over unassisted human officiating. While this is largely true, it also presents a false dilemma: that we can have accurately officiated sports or human officials, but not both. What this alleged dilemma ignores is that the criteria by which we measure accuracy are also up for revision. We could have sports that are so defined as to be easily (or at least more accurately) judged by human officials. A case from the recent history of science provides an instructive example. I argue that if we insist on human officials, we can still aim for maximal accuracy, though there will be tradeoffs. With compelling reasons to want accuracy in officiating, however, these tradeoffs effectively serve as a reductio against the use of human officials unaided by technology.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Neuropsychology Behind the PlateSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2017
- Rejecting Technology: A Normative Defense of Fallible OfficiatingSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2016
- Sport Records Are Social FactsSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2015
- Why Jim Joyce Wasn’t Wrong: Baseball and the Euthyphro DilemmaJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2015
- Call ‘Em as they are: What’s Wrong with Blown Calls and What to do about themJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2014
- Are there any Good Arguments Against Goal-Line Technology?Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2012
- Refereeing and Technology – Reflections on Collins’ ProposalsJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2012
- The Philosophy of Umpiring and the Introduction of Decision-Aid TechnologyJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2010
- Are Rules All an Umpire Has to Work With?Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 1999
- The Concept of a Call in BaseballJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 1997