Second Language Listening Instruction: Comparing a Strategies‐Based Approach With an Interactive, Strategies/Bottom‐Up Skills Approach
- 7 April 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in TESOL Quarterly
- Vol. 50 (2) , 394-420
Abstract
This quasi‐experimental study compared a strategies approach to second language listening instruction with an interactive approach, one combining a roughly equal balance of strategies and bottom‐up skills. The participants were lower‐intermediate‐level Taiwanese university EFL learners, who were taught for 22 hours over one and a half semesters. Their progress through the respective courses was charted via multiple instruments designed to assess growth in their listening proficiency, strategy use, bottom‐up skills, and affect‐related learner characteristics. Pretest and posttest one‐way ANOVAs showed no significant differences between the two groups on any of the dimensions tested. However, a repeated‐measures ANOVA showed significant gains by the strategies group in listening comprehension, but not by the interactive group. On this longitudinal within‐group comparison, the strategies group also demonstrated larger effect sizes than the interactive group for listening instruction, one measure of strategies growth, and the learner characteristics of confidence and motivation, whereas the interactive group showed larger effect sizes than the strategies group for all measures of bottom‐up skills involved. The outcome between the groups in terms of listening proficiency suggests that for lower‐intermediate‐level listeners, it is better to focus more on developing their listening strategies than to provide them with a balanced interactive approach.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Council (99-2410-H-030-088)
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Selective listening in L2 learners of FrenchLanguage Awareness, 2013
- Strategy Instruction in Listening for Lower‐Intermediate Learners of FrenchLanguage Learning, 2008
- Test review: GEPT: General English Proficiency TestLanguage Testing, 2008
- Strategies for Language Learning and for Language Use: Revising the Theoretical FrameworkThe Modern Language Journal, 2006
- Academic listening: Marrying top and bottom2006
- Areas of research that influence L2 listening instruction2006
- Learning how to listen using learning strategies2006
- 1. LISTENING TO LEARN OR LEARNING TO LISTEN?Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 2004
- Promoting perception: lexical segmentation in L2 listeningELT Journal, 2003
- Second Language Lexical Knowledge and Listening ComprehensionInternational Journal of Listening, 2000