Reply to S Berkemeyer

Authors:

Abstract
We thank Berkemeyer for calling attention once again to the question of how to compute, from diet composition data, the contribution of endogenous organic acid production (EOAP) to net endogenous acid production (NEAP). We take the opportunity to call the readers’ attention to our previous detailed explanation that EOAP’s contribution to daily NEAP depends on the amount of organic anions excreted daily in the urine, those excreted organic anions representing organic acids endogenously produced that the body does not metabolize to carbon dioxide and water and whose conjugate bases (organic anions) excreted in the urine must have left retained an equivalent amount of hydrogen ion as a component of NEAP (1). Inasmuch as experimental data indicate that diet composition modulates the rate of organic anion excretion (2–5), we remain skeptical of Berkemeyer’s premise that the contribution of EOAP to NEAP depends only on body size across all diets, net acid– and base–producing diets. We made our best estimate at organic anion excretion rate from experimental data showing that this rate in the steady state can be estimated from the so-called unmeasured anion content of the diet (3).

This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit: