Contextual factors and clinical reasoning: differences in diagnostic and therapeutic reasoning in board certified versus resident physicians
Authors:
- Elexis McBeeEMElexis McBee
- Temple RatcliffeTRTemple Ratcliffe
- Katherine PichoKPKatherine Picho
- Lambert SchuwirthLSLambert Schuwirth
- Anthony R. ArtinoJr.AAAnthony R. ArtinoJr.
- Ana Monica Yepes-RiosAYAna Monica Yepes-Rios
- Jennifer MaselJMJennifer Masel
- Cees van der VleutenCVCees van der Vleuten
- Steven J. DurningSDSteven J. Durning
Open Access
- 15 November 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 17 (1) , 211
Abstract
The impact of context on the complex process of clinical reasoning is not well understood. Using situated cognition as the theoretical framework and videos to provide the same contextual “stimulus” to all participants, we examined the relationship between specific contextual factors on diagnostic and therapeutic reasoning accuracy in board certified internists versus resident physicians. Each participant viewed three videotaped clinical encounters portraying common diagnoses in internal medicine. We explicitly modified the context to assess its impact on performance (patient and physician contextual factors). Patient contextual factors, including English as a second language and emotional volatility, were portrayed in the videos. Physician participant contextual factors were self-rated sleepiness and burnout.. The accuracy of diagnostic and therapeutic reasoning was compared with covariates using Fisher Exact, Mann-Whitney U tests and Spearman Rho’s correlations as appropriate. Fifteen board certified internists and 10 resident physicians participated from 2013 to 2014. Accuracy of diagnostic and therapeutic reasoning did not differ between groups despite residents reporting significantly higher rates of sleepiness (mean rank 20.45 vs 8.03, U = 0.5, p < .001) and burnout (mean rank 20.50 vs 8.00, U = 0.0, p < .001). Accuracy of diagnosis and treatment were uncorrelated (r = 0.17, p = .65). In both groups, the proportion scoring correct responses for treatment was higher than the proportion scoring correct responses for diagnosis. This study underscores that specific contextual factors appear to impact clinical reasoning performance. Further, the processes of diagnostic and therapeutic reasoning, although related, may not be interchangeable. This raises important questions about the impact that contextual factors have on clinical reasoning and provides insight into how clinical reasoning processes in more authentic settings may be explained by situated cognition theory.Keywords
Funding Information
- MedU/iIn Time
- Intramural Grant Funding
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Developing a Unified List of Physicians’ Reasoning Tasks During Clinical EncountersAcademic Medicine, 2013
- The feasibility, reliability, and validity of a post-encounter form for evaluating clinical reasoningMedical Teacher, 2012
- Context and clinical reasoning: understanding the perspective of the expert’s voiceMedical Education, 2011
- The impact of selected contextual factors on experts’ clinical reasoning performance (does context impact clinical reasoning performance in experts?)Advances in Health Sciences Education, 2011
- Situativity theory: A perspective on how participants and the environment can interact: AMEE Guide no. 52Medical Teacher, 2011
- Perspective: Redefining Context in the Clinical Encounter: Implications for Research and Training in Medical EducationAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Burnout and Suicidal Ideation among U.S. Medical StudentsAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2008
- Linking physician burnout and patient outcomesHealth Care Management Review, 2008
- Scripts and clinical reasoningMedical Education, 2007
- What every teacher needs to know about clinical reasoningMedical Education, 2004