Approaches to performance appraisal in TQM-driven organizations: does control vs. learning approach matter?
- 11 May 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Production Planning & Control
- Vol. 35 (12) , 1429-1450
Abstract
While prior studies provide insights into how Total Quality Management (TQM) and Performance Appraisal (PA) are incongruent, they rarely offer any compelling evidence that identifies the reasons behind the incongruence. We argue that the ‘why’ of TQM goals (i.e. control and learning) have consequences for the PA processes and purposes. Drawing from attribution theory and the duality inherent in TQM, our aim is to investigate how an organization’s preferred approach to TQM could result in different PA processes and purposes, particularly in relation to the manager’s understanding, diagnosis, and attributions of employee performance variation. To reach this purpose, a qualitative, inductively oriented investigation was conducted. Our findings suggest the disutility of a unilateral focus on either control or learning in terms of designing a PA system solely for the purpose of supporting one goal at the expense of the other. Rather, mutual understanding of the causes of performance variation and a recognition of shared responsibility for performance outcomes should become the core of the organization’s approach to TQM—if the PA system is to achieve the aim of continuous quality improvement and learning. We also present several working propositions that not only delineate how each goal of TQM could lead to different PA processes and purposes but also are of value to guide future research.Keywords
This publication has 107 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Psychological Processes of Cultural RetoolingAcademy of Management Journal, 2013
- Appraising Performance across Borders: An Empirical Examination of the Purposes and Practices of Performance Appraisal in a Multi‐Country ContextJournal of Management Studies, 2010
- The Social Context of Performance Appraisal: A Review and Framework for the FutureJournal of Management, 2004
- Why Total Quality Management Programs Do Not Persist: The Role of Management Quality and Implications for Leading a TQM Transformation*Decision Sciences, 2003
- Total quality management as competitive advantage: A review and empirical studyStrategic Management Journal, 1995
- At Last, an Alternative to Performance Appraisal: Total Quality ManagementPublic Administration Review, 1994
- From job‐based to competency‐based organizationsJournal of Organizational Behavior, 1994
- Investigating Supervisor Attributions of Subordinate PerformanceJournal of Management, 1989
- Putting Together the Pieces: A Closer Look at the Determinants of Job PerformanceHuman Performance, 1989
- Observers' focus of attention in the simulation of self-perception.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1977