Organised Assistance to Suicide in England?
Authors:
- 8 September 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Care Analysis
- Vol. 21 (2) , 85-104
Abstract
Guidelines provided by the Director of Public Prosecutions suggest that anyone assisting another to commit suicide in England and Wales, or elsewhere, will not be prosecuted provided there are no self-seeking motives and no active encouragement. This reflects the position in Switzerland. There, however, no difference is made between assistance and inducement. In addition, the Swiss approach makes it possible to establish organisations to assist the suicides of both their citizens and foreign visitors. It should not be assumed that this approach is without controversy in Switzerland. Proposals for reform continue to be debated there, not least because of the concern about some of the actual practices of certain end-of-life organisations. It is likely that a few English citizens will continue to avail themselves of these services in Switzerland if they cannot find the help they require here. This paper explores the legitimacy of the current restrictive position adopted towards assisted suicide in England. It argues that the provisions within the guidelines prohibiting organisations that assist suicides, leaves some without the help they need. While legislative decriminalisation of assisted suicide and the establishment of state-sponsored suicide centres would represent the most permissive regime, this paper proposes that this would be a step too far. The preference here is for decriminalisation but adopting a ‘middle way’ between the two extremes: the more permissive approach provided by the ‘Swiss model’ is one that could be employed here, albeit within a more robust regulatory regime.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Informal legal change on assisted suicide: the policy for prosecutorsLegal Studies, 2011
- ASSISTED DYING AND THE CONTEXT OF DEBATE: 'MEDICAL LAW' VERSUS 'END-OF-LIFE LAW'Medical Law Review, 2010
- Method of attempted suicide as predictor of subsequent successful suicide: national long term cohort studyBMJ, 2010
- PROSECUTORS MAKING (BAD) LAW?Medical Law Review, 2009
- Role of non-governmental organisations in physician assisted suicideBMJ, 2007
- PHYSICIAN ASSISTED SUICIDE: A NEW LOOK AT THE ARGUMENTSBioethics, 2007
- The case for physician assisted suicide: how can it possibly be proven?Journal of Medical Ethics, 2006
- Fallacies of the Logical Slippery Slope in the Debate on Physician-Assisted Suicide and EuthanasiaMedical Law Review, 2005
- Evidence for the Practical Slippery Slope in the Debate on Physician-Assisted Suicide and EuthanasiaMedical Law Review, 2005
- Is this a bad day, or one of the last days?: How to recognize and respond to approaching demiseJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2002