The Shadow of the Law: Adversarial Formalism in Prisoner-Staff Relations
Top Cited Papers
- 11 February 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Social Inquiry
- Vol. 50 (2) , 349-377
Abstract
The law is commonly described as one of the major forces shaping contemporary correctional institutions. However, we still lack a satisfactory understanding of how it has affected power relations behind bars. Drawing from two ethnographies of French correctional facilities, this article finds that changes to the material environment where incarcerated people and correctional staff interact have altered the relational economy of prisons and jails more than legal actions have. To avoid litigation, prison administrators design and use countless graphic artifacts, which has further reshaped the adversarial nature of social relations in prisons and jails. This bureaucratic approach has introduced the form of the law into the most banal of everyday communications between prisoners and authorities, replacing the informal asymmetrical interpersonal negotiations that have traditionally maintained order. Building on Robert Kagan’s typology of modes of policy making and dispute resolution, I re-examine power relations in contemporary French prisons and jails as a tension between formal and informal framings as well as hierarchical and participatory organizations of authority. I call this hybrid relational economy, where the force of the law lies mostly in its formal shadow, adversarial formalism.Keywords
This publication has 85 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Deviant Prison2021
- At Risk of Rights: Rehabilitation, Sentence Management and the Structural Violence of PrisonCritical Criminology, 2020
- Consensus in the Penal Field? Revisiting Breaking the PendulumLaw & Social Inquiry, 2019
- European monitoring of Belgian and French penal and prison policiesCrime, Law and Social Change, 2018
- European and United Nations monitoring of penal and prison policies as a source of an inverted panopticon?Crime, Law and Social Change, 2017
- Ethnography of Writings in Prison: Professional Power Struggles Surrounding a Digital Notebook in a Prison for Minors2015
- Human Rights in Prisons2015
- The Palgrave Handbook of Prison Ethnography2015
- Les économies morales revisitéesAnnales. Histoire, Sciences Sociales, 2009
- The Endogeneity of Legal Regulation: Grievance Procedures as Rational MythAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1999