In some valleys in northern Chile, the natural water reservoirs used for human consumption contain high levels of boron (> 25 mg/L). In local Pre-Colombian populations, this resulted in overexposure which is harmful to human health, causing gastrointestinal and other issues. Boron levels vary regionally, with the Lluta and Camarones Valleys presenting higher mean values (14 and 25 mg/L, respectively) than the Azapa Valley (1 mg/L). To estimate concentrations in northern Chile’s pre-Columbian populations, we used molecular absorption spectrophotometry to analyze rib samples of 211 individuals from these valleys. All the ancient rib samples presented mean boron values approximately 7 to 23 times higher than the 10.2 mg/Kg reported for modern bone tissue. Levels were highest in inhabitants of the Lluta Valley (235.52 mg/Kg) and Camarones Valley (119.09 mg/Kg), followed by those from the Azapa Valley (69.97 mg/Kg). We conclude that boron overexposure significantly impacted northern Chile’s ancient populations, and the discussions of pre-Columbian settlements and biocultural trajectories should consider water quality.