Surgeon Incivility in the Preoperative Setting: A Multi-institutional Crossover Study on Anesthesiology Residents’ Decision-Making
- 9 September 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Anesthesia & Analgesia
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Incivility in the perioperative setting is recognized as a threat to patient safety and workforce well-being. Anesthesiology residents are in a critical phase of developing professional judgment, making them potentially vulnerable to interpersonal dynamics. We sought to evaluate the impact of surgeon incivility on residents’ decisions to either proceed with or postpone surgery in simulated cases characterized by clinical equipoise. METHODS: We conducted a prospective, randomized, blinded, crossover study at two academic medical centers (Mount Sinai Health System and University of North Carolina) between September 2024 and April 2025. Participants were Postgraduate Year (PGY) 2 to 4 anesthesiology residents. Each resident completed two objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) scenarios—a medically complex case and an ethical dilemma—designed to be clinically ambiguous. Participants were randomized to interact with a standardized surgeon actor who displayed either civil (collaborative) or uncivil (rude, dismissive) behavior. Blinded attending anesthesiologists evaluated the residents’ decision to proceed or postpone and rated their performance using behaviorally anchored rating scales (BARS). RESULTS: After exclusions, 79 residents were analyzed in the logistic mixed-effects model. Residents exposed to the uncivil condition were significantly more likely to proceed with surgery than those in the civil condition (odds ratio = 2.25; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.07–4.74; P = .03). There were no statistically significant differences in resident performance scores between civil and uncivil encounters across the domains of situational awareness ( P = .50), communication ( P = .09), or decision-making ( P = .50). Apart from relationship status, demographic variables and personality traits did not significantly influence the primary outcome. Interclass correlation coefficients demonstrated moderate reliability among attending BARS performance ratings. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeon incivility significantly influenced anesthesiology residents to proceed with surgery in clinically ambiguous situations, overriding the tendency to postpone as observed in civil encounters. This shift occurred despite preserved performance scores, suggesting that incivility exerts a coercive influence on clinical judgment. Future studies are needed to characterize the effect of incivility across broader cohorts and to evaluate the efficacy of specific interventions intended to mitigate its impact.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exposure to incivility does not hinder speaking up: a randomised controlled high-fidelity simulation-based studyBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2022
- Discrimination, Abuse, Harassment, and Burnout in Surgical Residency TrainingNew England Journal of Medicine, 2019
- Workplace incivility and employee sleep: The role of rumination and recovery experiences.Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 2019
- Prevalence and predictors of exposure to disruptive behaviour in the operating roomCanadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie, 2019
- Challenging authority and speaking up in the operating room environment: a narrative synthesisBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2019
- Cancellation of Surgeries: Integrative ReviewJournal of PeriAnesthesia Nursing, 2019
- Improving Anesthesiologists’ Ability to Speak Up in the Operating RoomAcademic Medicine, 2016
- Harassment and Discrimination in Medical TrainingAcademic Medicine, 2014
- Empirical Validation and Psychometric Evaluation of the Brief Fear of Negative Evaluation Scale in Patients With Social Anxiety Disorder.Psychological Assessment, 2005
- Incivility in the workplace: Incidence and impact.Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 2001