We present a comprehensive approach to the automated formalization of legal texts using large language models (LLMs), into Defeasible Deontic Logic (DDL). Our method employs a structured pipeline that segments complex normative language into atomic snippets, extracts DDL rules, and evaluates them for syntactic and semantic coherence. We introduce a success metric that captures the completeness of formalizations, and a novel two-stage pipeline with a dedicated refinement step to improve logical consistency and coverage. We compare results across multiple LLM configurations, including newly released models and various prompting strategies. We discuss limitations arising from gold-standard dependence and implicit legal obligations, highlighting trade-offs between textual fidelity and normative completeness.Experiments on legal norms from the Australian Telecommunications Consumer Protections Code demonstrate that, when guided effectively, LLMs can produce formalizations that align closely with expert-crafted representations, underscoring their potential for scalable legal informatics.