Does immersive VR improve diagnostic accuracy of post-stroke spatial neglect relative to conventional and digital tests?
Preprint
Abstract
Objective: Assessing post-stroke spatial neglect in immersive Virtual Reality (iVR) may improve diagnostic accuracy due to its ability to combine experimental control with increased ecological validity. This study investigated the diagnostic accuracy of an iVR assessment relative to conventional and non-iVR digital tests. Additionally, feasibility was evaluated. Method: Stroke patients performed an iVR assessment, conventional pen-and-paper tests (3 Cancellation tests and a line bisection test), and non-iVR digital tests (Digital Cancellation and Posner test). A new Bayesian statistical method was developed to address the absence of a gold standard for neglect. Instead of conventional diagnostic cut-offs, we quantified the uncertainty of classifying patients as having neglect or not and incorporated this into estimating diagnostic accuracy. Feasibility was evaluated using recruitment and drop-out rates, sample characteristics, cybersickness and user experience. Results: 54 stroke patients and 56 healthy controls completed the study. Both iVR and non-iVR digital tests had higher diagnostic accuracies than pen-and-paper tests, although differences were not statistically significant due to high diagnostic uncertainty (resulting from inconsistencies across tests). For 6 patients, the iVR assessment and Posner test indicated neglect, while pen-and-paper tests did not. The iVR assessment was feasible for most patients, with low cybersickness and positive evaluations. Conclusion: The iVR assessment and Posner test identified spatial biases missed by conventional tests. Inconsistencies across tests highlight the complexity of neglect assessment, suggesting that future studies should explore crucial test characteristics needed for a precise and sensitive evaluation. Furthermore, results established good feasibility of iVR neglect assessment.Keywords
This publication has 70 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessment and treatment of visuospatial neglect using active learning with Gaussian processes regressionArtificial Intelligence in Medicine, 2024
- Predicting cybersickness using individual and task characteristicsComputers in Human Behavior, 2023
- Eyetracking during free visual exploration detects neglect more reliably than paper-pencil testsCortex, 2020
- Ready to be a Silver Surfer? A Meta-analysis on the Relationship Between Chronological Age and Technology AcceptanceComputers in Human Behavior, 2018
- Impact of Spatial Neglect on Stroke Rehabilitation: Evidence From the Setting of an Inpatient Rehabilitation FacilityArchives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 2015
- Improving the reporting of randomised trials: the CONSORT Statement and beyondStatistics in Medicine, 2012
- Is the Posner Reaction Time Test More Accurate Than Clinical Tests in Detecting Left Neglect in Acute and Chronic Stroke?Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 2009
- Weights and measures: A new look at bisection behaviour in neglectCognitive Brain Research, 2005
- Spontaneous eye and head position in patients with spatial neglectJournal of Neurology, 2005
- Do We Need the “Lateral” in Unilateral Neglect? Spatially Nonselective Attention Deficits in Unilateral Neglect and Their Implications for RehabilitationNeuroImage, 2001