No Such Things as Sodium and Chlorine Atoms: A Debate with Copilot
- 31 August 2025
- journal article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Education
- Vol. 102 (10) , 4455-4460
Abstract
One can find expressions such as “building blocks of matter”, “sodium and chlorine atoms in sodium chloride”, “atoms make up all substances”, “bromine replaced chlorine atoms in SN2 substitution”, or “the number of sodium atoms in the reactant and product sides” in books, articles, and personal communications. Some argue that such expressions create obstacles for students in understanding fundamental chemistry concepts like the particulate nature of matter, colligative properties, physical and chemical changes, and more advanced topics such as emergence and supervenience. Given students’ wide use of artificial intelligence (AI) tools such as Copilot and ChatGPT, we examined the nature of expressions AI generates to such prompts and drew ontological and conceptual implications. We developed a prompting protocol and used it for a debate with Copilot. We noted that Copilot generates similar types of misleading expressions. However, as the debate continued, Copilot adjusted its responses in a more adaptive way, gradually refining its explanations. Maintaining such an adaptive correction can be challenging for students. So, it is crucial to help students develop the desired evaluative habits through course assignments and discussions.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Metacognition and Critical Thinking: Using ChatGPT-Generated Responses as Prompts for Critique in a Problem-Solving Workshop (SMARTCHEMPer)Journal of Chemical Education, 2023
- Interview with the Chatbot: How Does It Reason?Journal of Chemical Education, 2023
- Improving the Understanding of Chemistry by Using the Right Words: A Clear-Cut Strategy to Avoid Misconceptions When Talking about Elements, Atoms, and MoleculesJournal of Chemical Education, 2022
- When Atoms WantJournal of Chemical Education, 2013
- Alan F. Chalmers: The Scientist’s Atom and the Philosopher’s Stone: How Science Succeeded and Philosophy Failed to Gain Knowledge of AtomsScience & Education, 2010
- Atomism before Dalton2010
- Four Centuries of Atomic Theory2010
- Presentation of atomic structure in Turkish general chemistry textbooksChemistry Education Research and Practice, 2009
- Why there is No Salt in the SeaFoundations of Chemistry, 2005
- The Atom in the Chemistry Curriculum: Fundamental Concept, Teaching Model or Epistemological Obstacle?Foundations of Chemistry, 2003