Species as Stories: Recognizing the Biocultural Legacy of Natural History
Authors:
Preprint
- 12 May 2026
- preprint
- Published by Wiley
Abstract
1. Natural history connects biodiversity with culture and memory — it encompasses not only the biological traits of species but also the historical and cultural contexts of their discovery, classification, and naming. 2. Eponyms are not neutral — whether scientific binomials or English common names, they function as cultural markers that reveal the interaction of science, society, and personal legacy. 3. Contemporary debates — the American Ornithological Society’s decision to replace eponymous common names of birds foregrounds inclusivity and equity, while also raising broader questions about the historical narratives embedded in scientific nomenclature. 4. Analytical framework — drawing on biocultural diversity and memory, we propose a layered approach that treats names as historically embedded, multi-dimensional objects and outline five intersecting layers (historical–institutional, narrative, biocultural embeddedness, power/harm, and knowledge continuity), which can be profiled qualitatively or with a simple ordinal coding scheme. 5. Case studies — examples from Audubon, Sclater, women in natural history, and contentious taxa, such as Rhynchophanes mccownii and Peucaea aestivalis, show how names crystallize both scientific innovation and the prejudices of their age; Indigenous knowledge, though often overlooked, has also been fundamental to biodiversity research and naming practices. 6. A way forward — rather than erasure, contextualization provides balance: retaining eponyms within scientific nomenclature for critical reflection, while integrating Indigenous and local perspectives to foster a richer and more inclusive understanding of biodiversity. By offering a structured and transparent approach to evaluating naming controversies, this framework can support more consistent and historically informed decisions within biodiversity governance.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Journal of Ornithology, 1.