Early‐Career Publishing and Reviewing: Pitfalls and Perspectives
Open Access
- 3 June 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in The Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America
- Vol. 106 (3)
Abstract
While the publishing landscape has drastically changed in recent decades, publishing productivity metrics (e.g., citation scores) and support for early‐career researchers (ECRs) have not kept pace. ECRs are individuals currently in school, up to 8 years post final degree, or on the job market, and being an ECR is inherently characterized by transitions that coincide with potential career instability and pressure to find a permanent job. The global pandemic years exacerbated the publishing challenges ECRs faced, from reviewer scarcity to publishing equity gaps across gender and race. We sought to evaluate ECR attitudes towards publishing, reviewing, and open access (OA), as well as identify common barriers ECRs encountered in the current publishing system. We solicited ECR perspectives by distributing a survey to ECRs from September to October of 2023, resulting in 162 self‐identified ECRs in ecology, including students (38%), postdoctoral scholars (29%), those in permanent positions (31%; e.g., faculty, state, and federal government), or working outside ecology altogether (2%). Overwhelmingly, cost, reviewer compensation, time constraints, and insufficient mentorship were the major barriers identified by ECRs. We suggest that institutions, journal publishers, mid‐ and late‐career ecologists, and professional societies adopt focused strategies to support ECRs through more diverse and inclusive financial support for publishing, broader metrics to measure scientific productivity beyond traditional citation‐based metrics, additional means to compensate reviewers, and training and mentorship to students and postdoctoral researchers on reviewer expectations and etiquette. Several survey respondents also noted that the publishing system would be more equitable if all scientific journals transitioned to double‐blind peer review. If scientific organizations, institutions, and publishers wish to promote a sustainable and diverse scientific publishing system in the future, they need to focus on the needs and challenges of early‐career researchers.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Action to support early career ecologistsFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2022
- How burnout and imposter syndrome blight scientific careersNature, 2021
- Unequal effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on scientistsNature Human Behaviour, 2020
- Are women publishing less during the pandemic? Here’s what the data sayNature, 2020
- What do we know about university academics' mental health? A systematic literature reviewStress and Health, 2020
- Academic ecosystems must evolve to support a sustainable postdoc workforceNature Ecology & Evolution, 2020
- Where Do All the STEM Graduates Go? Higher Education, the Labour Market and Career Trajectories in the UKJournal of Science Education and Technology, 2018
- Careers in ecology: a fine‐scale investigation of national data from the U.S. Survey of Doctorate RecipientsEcosphere, 2017
- Value all research productsNature, 2013
- Intended and unintended consequences of a publish‐or‐perish culture: A worldwide surveyJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2012