Principal job satisfaction across 27 education systems: trends and within-system associations with staffing shortages and workload, 2013–2024

Authors:
  • JMJosé Miguel
    José Miguel
  • JAJulio Alfredo
    Julio Alfredo
  • CRCarlos Roberto
    Carlos Roberto

Abstract
Introduction: Principal job satisfaction is an indicator of occupational wellbeing and leadership sustainability, yet international evidence on temporal change and organizational correlates remains limited. Methods: Harmonized TALIS 2013, 2018, and 2024 principal records ( n = 16,257) were used to obtain design-based estimates for 54−81 education-system-by-cycle cells. The fixed-effects models were estimated at the system-cycle level, with 26 or 27 education systems serving as clustering units. System-cycle estimates incorporated final school weights and 100 Fay-BRR replicate weights; association models used system and cycle fixed effects and CR2/Satterthwaite inference. Results: Job satisfaction was virtually unchanged between 2013 and 2018 and modestly lower by 2024, although temporal contrasts were not conclusive after Holm adjustment. Staffing-shortage and workload indices were negatively associated with satisfaction but imprecisely estimated. Retaining the original four shortage-response categories preserved the negative direction of all staffing coefficients. A 10,000-draw sensitivity analysis that propagated Fay-BRR uncertainty in both outcome and predictor estimates increased uncertainty without changing the substantive interpretation. In exploratory component-level analyses, additional duties arising from staff absence showed the strongest negative association and remained below the within-family false-discovery-rate threshold in single and joint models. Discussion: The findings distinguish broad organizational pressures from specific operational burdens. The aggregate evidence is directionally consistent but uncertain, and the staff-absence result is exploratory; neither supports individual-level or causal claims.

This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit: