Feedback is essential for enhancing student learning with complex tasks, but creating it is often time-consuming for teachers. Artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models, can support teachers in providing feedback. However, teachers’ use of AI depends on their perceptions of the AI-generated feedback. Drawing on the social identity theory (Tajfel & Turner, 1979), it is hypothesised that teachers prefer feedback from fellow teachers (their ingroup) to AI-generated feedback (an outgroup); this leads to lower perception ratings of AI feedback compared to teacher feedback. This study experimentally examined whether the same feedback would be perceived negatively when labelled as “AI-generated” rather than when labelled as “teacher-generated” and whether providing teachers with additional information on AI’s functionality would influence this effect. A sample of 401 English-speaking teachers read three student essays, each with two AI-generated feedback messages, randomly labelled as AI-generated or teacher-generated. They indicated their perceptions of the feedback messages regarding credibility, usefulness, and fairness, as well as their feedback preference (teacher vs. AI). The results revealed that feedback perceptions were significantly less favourable for feedback labelled as AI-generated than for feedback labelled as teacher-generated, with the majority of teachers preferring teacher-labelled feedback to AI-labelled feedback (73% vs. 27%). These findings demonstrate that teachers systematically rate identical feedback as less credible, useful, and fair when it is labelled as AI-generated rather than teacher-generated, suggesting a negative bias that may have implications for the adoption of effective AI feedback in educational practice.