Governing dual objectives within single policy mixes: an empirical analysis of large carnivore policies in six European countries
Authors:
- Auvikki de BoonABAuvikki de Boon
- Camilla SandströmCSCamilla Sandström
- Ugo ArbieuUAUgo Arbieu
- Inger HansenIHInger Hansen
- Lisa LehnenLLLisa Lehnen
- Agnese MarinoAMAgnese Marino
- Mari Pohja-MykräMPMari Pohja-Mykrä
- Camilla RisvollCRCamilla Risvoll
- Geir-Harald StrandGSGeir-Harald Strand
- Katrina RønningenKRKatrina Rønningen
Open Access
- 3 November 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning
- Vol. 23 (4) , 399-413
Abstract
Policy mixes (i.e. the total structure of policy processes, strategies, and instruments) are complex constructs that can quickly become incoherent, inconsistent, and incomprehensive. This is amplified when the policy mix strives to meet multiple objectives simultaneously, such as in the case of large carnivore policy mixes. Building on Rogge and Reichardt's analytical framework for the analysis of policy mixes, we compare the policy mixes of Norway, Sweden, Finland, the Netherlands, Germany (specifically Saxony and Bavaria), and Spain (specifically Castilla y León). The study shows that the large carnivore policy mixes in the case countries show signs of lacking vertical and horizontal coherence in the design of policy processes, weak consistency between objectives and designated policy instruments, and, as a consequence, lacking comprehensiveness. We conclude that creating consistent, coherent, and comprehensive policy mixes that build on multiple objectives requires stepping away from sectorized policy development, toward a holistic, systemic approach, strong collaborative structures across policy boundaries and regions, the inclusion of diverse stakeholders, and constant care and attention to address all objectives simultaneously rather than in isolation.Keywords
Funding Information
- Research Council of Norway (267982)
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Realigning the land-sharing/land-sparing debate to match conservation needs: considering diversity scales and land-use historyLandscape Ecology, 2014
- Performance Payments for Groups: The Case of Carnivore Conservation in Northern SwedenEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2013
- The Governance of the Wolf-Human Relationship in EuropeReview of European Studies, 2013
- The Golden Eagle Compensation Scheme in Finland as an Example of Incentive Measures2013
- Governing Towards Sustainability—Conceptualizing Modes of GovernanceJournal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 2013
- Implementing transition management as policy reforms: a case study of the Dutch energy sectorPolicy Sciences, 2009
- Estimating cost functions for the four large carnivores in SwedenEcological Economics, 2008
- Finland's Wolf Policy and New GovernanceThe Journal of Environment & Development, 2008
- Are innovative, participatory and deliberative procedures in policy making democratic and effective?European Journal of Political Research, 2007
- Systematically Pinching Ideas: A Comparative Approach to Policy DesignJournal of Public Policy, 1988