Popper, Weber, and Hayek: The epistemology and politics of ignorance
Author:
- Jeffrey FriedmanJFJeffrey Friedman
- 1 January 2005
- journal article
- other
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Critical Review
- Vol. 17 (1-2) , 1-58
Abstract
Karl Popper's methodology highlights our scientific ignorance: hence the need to institutionalize open‐mindedness through controlled experiments that may falsify our fallible theories about the world. In his endorsement of “piecemeal social engineering,” Popper assumes that the social‐democratic state and its citizens are capable of detecting social problems, and of assessing the results of policies aimed at solving them, through a process of experimentation analogous to that of natural science. But we are not only scientifically but politically ignorant: ignorant of the facts that underpin political debate, which are brought to our attention by theories that, as Max Weber emphasized, can be tested only through counterfactual thought experiments. Public‐opinion and political‐psychology research suggest that human beings are far too unaware, illogical, and doctrinaire to conduct the rigorous theorizing that would be necessary to make piecemeal social engineering work. F.A. Hayek realized that the public could not engage, specifically, in piecemeal economic regulation but failed to draw the conclusion that this was due to a specific type of political ignorance: ignorance of economic theory.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Popper and the establishmentCritical Review, 2005
- The Feeling of Rationality: The Meaning of Neuroscientific Advances for Political SciencePerspectives on Politics, 2004
- From Hayek to Keynes: G.L.S. shackle and ignorance of the futureCritical Review, 2004
- Is the public's ignorance of politics trivial?Critical Review, 2003
- You don't know me, but I know you: The illusion of asymmetric insight.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2001
- Democracy despite voter ignorance: A Weberian reply to Somin and FriedmanCritical Review, 1999
- Rationality reconceived: The mass electorate and democratic theoryCritical Review, 1998
- Voter ignorance and the democratic idealCritical Review, 1998
- Where did economics go wrong? Modern economics as a flight from realityCritical Review, 1997
- DEGREES OF EXPLANATIONThe British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 1955