Harmful algal blooms pose a global threat to human health, marine ecosystems and economic activities. Blooms of Karenia species, including K. mikimotoi, K. brevisulcata, and K. selliformis have been associated with mass mortalities of marine fauna and aquaculture species worldwide, including New Zealand. This study investigated the toxicity of cultures and fractions of Karenia spp. to the reproduction and recruitment of green-lipped mussels, an important aquaculture species in New Zealand. This was conducted at environmentally relevant bloom concentrations, using bioassays targeting mussel spermatozoa and embryo–larval development. A slight reduction (up to 2.5%) in sperm viability was observed after exposure to K. mikimotoi and K. papilionacea at 1.5 × 10³ and 8 × 10³ cells mL⁻¹, respectively, accompanied by a 1.6–2.9-fold increase in spermatozoa intracellular reactive oxygen species production, relative to the seawater controls. Embryo–larval development was strongly affected by K. papilionacea, K. mikimotoi and K. selliformis cultures, with reduced D-larvae viable rate to 30–41% compared to 75% in the controls. At 10³ cells mL⁻¹, extracellular fractions of K. mikimotoi and K. selliformis induced larval degradation at similar level than whole cultures, suggesting toxicity of whole culture is entirely explained by extracellular toxic compounds. Intracellular fractions of K. selliformis induced up to 98% larval degradation, as opposed to K. mikimotoi, highlighting different toxicity mechanisms. These results indicate that Karenia blooms may exert significant embryotoxic effects on the green-lipped mussel, potentially impairing recruitment and aquaculture sustainability, highlighting the need for increased monitoring during the reproductive period.