Multiple Score Comparison: a network meta-analysis approach to comparison and external validation of prognostic scores
Open Access
- 21 December 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Research Methodology
- Vol. 17 (1) , 172
Abstract
Prediction models and prognostic scores have been increasingly popular in both clinical practice and clinical research settings, for example to aid in risk-based decision making or control for confounding. In many medical fields, a large number of prognostic scores are available, but practitioners may find it difficult to choose between them due to lack of external validation as well as lack of comparisons between them. Borrowing methodology from network meta-analysis, we describe an approach to Multiple Score Comparison meta-analysis (MSC) which permits concurrent external validation and comparisons of prognostic scores using individual patient data (IPD) arising from a large-scale international collaboration. We describe the challenges in adapting network meta-analysis to the MSC setting, for instance the need to explicitly include correlations between the scores on a cohort level, and how to deal with many multi-score studies. We propose first using IPD to make cohort-level aggregate discrimination or calibration scores, comparing all to a common comparator. Then, standard network meta-analysis techniques can be applied, taking care to consider correlation structures in cohorts with multiple scores. Transitivity, consistency and heterogeneity are also examined. We provide a clinical application, comparing prognostic scores for 3-year mortality in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease using data from a large-scale collaborative initiative. We focus on the discriminative properties of the prognostic scores. Our results show clear differences in performance, with ADO and eBODE showing higher discrimination with respect to mortality than other considered scores. The assumptions of transitivity and local and global consistency were not violated. Heterogeneity was small. We applied a network meta-analytic methodology to externally validate and concurrently compare the prognostic properties of clinical scores. Our large-scale external validation indicates that the scores with the best discriminative properties to predict 3 year mortality in patients with COPD are ADO and eBODE.Keywords
Funding Information
- Universität Zürich
This publication has 71 references indexed in Scilit:
- Is network meta-analysis as valid as standard pairwise meta-analysis? It all depends on the distribution of effect modifiersBMC Medicine, 2013
- New Models for Large Prospective Studies: Is There a Better Way?American Journal of Epidemiology, 2012
- Dealing With Missing Outcome Data in Randomized Trials and Observational StudiesAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 2011
- Problems With Risk Reclassification Methods for Evaluating Prediction ModelsAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 2011
- External Validity of Risk Models: Use of Benchmark Values to Disentangle a Case-Mix Effect From Incorrect CoefficientsAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 2010
- Imputing missing covariate values for the Cox modelStatistics in Medicine, 2009
- The SAFE (SGRQ score, air-flow limitation and exercise tolerance) Index: a new composite score for the stratification of severity in chronic obstructive pulmonary diseasePostgraduate Medical Journal, 2007
- Combination of direct and indirect evidence in mixed treatment comparisonsStatistics in Medicine, 2004
- How should meta‐regression analyses be undertaken and interpreted?Statistics in Medicine, 2002
- Meta-analysis in clinical trialsControlled Clinical Trials, 1986