An integrated ecotoxicological study reliability framework for use in toxicity value development
Open Access
- 28 January 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 44 (4) , 1142-1153
Abstract
A key component of ecological risk assessments is to develop evidence-based benchmarks to assess potential hazards to various receptors. To ensure that toxicity value development is performed using the best available science, the reliability (or inherent scientific quality) of these studies must be considered. The degree of reliability can be evaluated via critical appraisal tools (CATs), though application of such methods assessing ecotoxicological literature for toxicity value development is not well established compared to human health assessments. A review of existing CATs revealed that there is currently no approach that considers the full range of biases that should be considered for appraisal of internal validity in ecotoxicological studies. Recognizing the need for a comprehensive ecotoxicity study assessment framework that addresses risk of bias (RoB) for the interpretation of study reliability, we propose the Ecotoxicological Study Reliability (EcoSR) framework. This framework builds upon the classic RoB assessment approach, frequently applied in human health assessments. EcoSR adds reliability and key criteria specific to ecotoxicity studies from existing appraisal methods, emphasizing those used by regulatory bodies. Additionally, the framework recommends a priori customization based on assessment goals. EcoSR is comprised of two tiers: an optional preliminary screening (Tier 1) and a full reliability assessment (Tier 2). The framework outlines a systematic approach for conducting ecotoxicity study appraisals that enhances transparency and consistency in determining study reliability. The EcoSR framework provides flexibility and can be refined and applied to a variety of chemical classes. This framework represents a significant step towards improving the transparency and reproducibility of ecotoxicological study appraisals; ultimately, contributing to more informed and reliable toxicity value development within the ecological sciences.Keywords
Funding Information
- 3M
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Implementation of the CREED approach for environmental assessmentsIntegrated Environmental Assessment and Management, 2024
- Systematic evaluation of the evidence for identification of endocrine disrupting properties of Bisphenol FToxicology, 2022
- Evaluating reliability and risk of bias of in vivo animal data for risk assessment of chemicals – Exploring the use of the SciRAP tool in a systematic review contextEnvironment International, 2021
- Facilitation of risk assessment with evidence-based methods – A framework for use of systematic mapping and systematic reviews in determining hazard, developing toxicity values, and characterizing uncertaintyRegulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 2020
- Recommendations for the conduct of systematic reviews in toxicology and environmental health research (COSTER)Environment International, 2020
- Risk‐of‐bias VISualization (robvis): An R package and Shiny web app for visualizing risk‐of‐bias assessmentsResearch Synthesis Methods, 2020
- Assessing the reliability of ecotoxicological studies: An overview of current needs and approachesIntegrated Environmental Assessment and Management, 2016
- Evaluation of the ToxRTool’s ability to rate the reliability of toxicological data for human health hazard assessmentsRegulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 2015
- “ToxRTool”, a new tool to assess the reliability of toxicological dataToxicology Letters, 2009
- A Systematic Approach for Evaluating the Quality of Experimental Toxicological and Ecotoxicological DataRegulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 1997