Comparative study of fault tree analysis and 24Model: taking the cause analysis of the Quanzhou Xinjia Hotel collapse accident as an example
- 3 October 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergonomics
- Vol. 30 (1) , 108-118
Abstract
A comparative study was conducted to compare the accident cause analysis methods of Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) and 24Model. A major accident - Xinjia Hotel collapse accident was selected as the research object, the causes of the accident were reanalysed and accident prevention countermeasures were designed based on 24Model and FTA respectively, and the systematic characteristics of 24Model were summarized. The research shows that both 24Model and FTA can carry out risk assessment, accident cause analysis and preventive countermeasure design based on their own rules. Different from FTA, 24Model has static and dynamic structures of specific forms, the definition of causes and factors in the model is more comprehensive and the analysis method is more hierarchical and normative. 24Model can analyse the deep-level cultural and system causes, but the analysis process does not use quantitative methods, only use qualitative methods. 24Model has 8 systematic characteristics, such as integrity, hierarchy and dynamics.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (51534008)
- Chinese Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (2021YJSAQ26)
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Analysis of an explosion accident at Dangyang Power Plant in Hubei, China: Causes and lessons learnedSafety Science, 2018
- An Application of 24Model to Analyse Capsizing of the Eastern Star FerryPolish Maritime Research, 2017
- An overview of fault tree analysis and its application in model based dependability analysisExpert Systems with Applications, 2017
- ‘Remixing Rasmussen’: The evolution of Accimaps within systemic accident analysisApplied Ergonomics, 2017
- Fuzzy temporal fault tree analysis of dynamic systemsInternational Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 2016
- Systems thinking, the Swiss Cheese Model and accident analysis: A comparative systemic analysis of the Grayrigg train derailment using the ATSB, AcciMap and STAMP modelsAccident Analysis & Prevention, 2014
- Systems-based accident analysis methods: A comparison of Accimap, HFACS, and STAMPSafety Science, 2012
- Hazard Analysis Techniques for System Safety2005
- Applications of fault tree analysis to maintenance interval extension and vulnerability assessmentProcess Safety Progress, 2005
- Fault trees for security system design and analysisComputers & Security, 2003