Policy Networks and Industrial Revitalization: High Speed Rail Initiatives in France and Germany
Authors:
- James A. DunnJDJames A. Dunn
- Anthony PerlAPAnthony Perl
- 1 July 1994
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Public Policy
- Vol. 14 (3) , 311-343
Abstract
Using Atkinson and Coleman's typology of policy networks, this article shows how many of the differences in policy outcomes can be traced to the structure of the policy environment in each nation. French and Germany policy makers adopted a strategy of investing in high speed passenger transport to revitalize their declining railway sectors. The French TGV was developed in a state-directed policy network which insisted on cost containment and commercial viability. In Germany a corporatist style of policymaking in the rail sector led to delays and higher costs for the ICE train. A separate clientele pluralist network led by the Research Ministry developed the Transrapid maglev option, but in order to finance and deploy an operational system, the Chancellor and cabinet had to create a concertation network. The policy network approach provides a useful framework for conducting comparative analysis. In addition, these detailed cases suggest that it is useful to add a dynamic, cross-temporal dimension to the static typology.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- ICE‐design and operational aspectsJournal of Advanced Transportation, 1993
- Transrapid maglev system technical readiness and corridors of applicationJournal of Advanced Transportation, 1993
- Entre le local et l'Europe. La crise du modèle français de politiques publiquesRevue française de science politique, 1992
- Strong States and Weak States: Sectoral Policy Networks in Advanced Capitalist EconomiesBritish Journal of Political Science, 1989
- Policy Community, Policy Network and Comparative Industrial PoliciesPolitical Studies, 1988
- National Styles and Policy Sectors: Explaining Structured VariationJournal of Public Policy, 1985
- The Politics of Transport in Twentieth-Century France1984
- THE GERMAN FEDERAL RAILWAYS—A STATE ADMINISTERED SYSTEMParliamentary Affairs, 1963