Diagnosing swine flu: the inaccuracy of case definitions during the 2009 pandemic, an attempt at refinement, and the implications for future planning
Open Access
- 19 June 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses
- Vol. 7 (3) , 403-409
Abstract
Background At the onset of the pandemic H1N1/09 influenza A outbreak in Australia, health authorities devised official clinical case definitions to guide testing and access to antiviral therapy. Objectives To assess the diagnostic accuracy of these case definitions and to attempt to improve on them using a scoring system based on clinical findings at presentation. Patients/Methods This study is a retrospective case–control study across three metropolitan Melbourne hospitals and one associated community-based clinic during the influenza season, 2009. Patients presenting with influenza-like illness who were tested for H1N1/09 influenza A were administered a standard questionnaire of symptomatology, comorbidities, and risk factors. Patients with a positive test were compared to those with a negative test. Logistic regression was performed to examine for correlation of clinical features with disease. A scoring system was devised and compared with case definitions used during the pandemic. The main outcome measures were the positive and negative predictive values of our scoring system, based on real-life data, versus the mandated case definitions’. Results Both the devised scoring system and the case definitions gave similar positive predictive values (38–58% using ascending score groups, against 39–44% using the various case definitions). Negative predictive values were also closely matched (ranging from 94% to 73% in the respective score groups against 83–84% for the case definitions). Conclusions Accurate clinical diagnosis of H1N1/09 influenza A was difficult and not improved significantly by a structured scoring system. Investment in more widespread availability of rapid and sensitive diagnostic tests should be considered in future pandemic planning.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Risk Factors for Severe Outcomes following 2009 Influenza A (H1N1) Infection: A Global Pooled AnalysisPLOS Medicine, 2011
- Adult outpatient experience of the 2009 H1N1 pandemic: Clinical course, pathogens, and evaluation of case definitionsJournal of Infection, 2011
- Clinical and laboratory features distinguishing pandemic H1N1 influenza-related pneumonia from interpandemic community-acquired pneumonia in adultsThorax, 2011
- Evaluation of an influenza-like illness case definition in the diagnosis of influenza among patients with acute febrile illness in cambodiaBMC Infectious Diseases, 2010
- Influenza A (H1N1) in Victoria, Australia: A Community Case Series and Analysis of Household TransmissionPLOS ONE, 2010
- Hospital Triage System for Adult Patients Using an Influenza-Like Illness Scoring System during the 2009 Pandemic—MexicoPLOS ONE, 2010
- Shedding and Transmission of Novel Influenza Virus A/H1N1 Infection in Households--Germany, 2009American Journal of Epidemiology, 2010
- Emergence of a Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) Virus in HumansNew England Journal of Medicine, 2009
- Performance Characteristics of Clinical Diagnosis, a Clinical Decision Rule, and a Rapid Influenza Test in the Detection of Influenza Infection in a Community Sample of AdultsAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2005
- Predicting Influenza Infections during Epidemics with Use of a Clinical Case DefinitionClinical Infectious Diseases, 2000