A COMPARISON OF TESTS FOR EXTRACTABLE COPPER AND ZINC IN METAL-SPIKED AND FIELD-CONTAMINATED SOIL
- 1 August 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Soil Science
- Vol. 174 (8) , 439-444
Abstract
Common soil test methods were compared with 0.01 M CaCl2 extraction to determine their relative abilities to extract and estimate phytoavailability of Cu and Zn. In aged metal-spiked soils, all soil tests evaluated (Mehlich 3, diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid [DTPA], Morgan, modified Morgan, CaCl2) showed a linear relationship of extractable to total Cu and Zn for both soil types studied. The fraction of total Cu and Zn extracted by aggressive tests (Mehlich 3, DTPA) was much higher than the fraction extracted by CaCl2, with the Morgan tests being intermediate. Although all extraction methods revealed Cu and Zn to be more available in the coarse-textured soil than the fine-textured soil, this texture effect was greatest for the least aggressive test (CaCl2) and least for Mehlich 3. The texture effect on soil test Cu and Zn was also reflected in bioavailability, with greater plant tissue concentrations of both metals from the coarse-textured soil in a soybean assay. Although all soil test methods provided similarly strong correlations to plant tissue concentrations of Zn for soybeans grown in the two soils, the less aggressive soil tests seemed more reliable as predictors of Cu uptake. The efficiency of Cu and Zn extraction from field-contaminated soils was much lower than that from laboratory-spiked aged soils. For Mehlich 3 and DTPA tests, Cu and Zn in field-contaminated soils were less extractable by a factor of about 2 compared with the spiked soils. For less aggressive tests, the difference in extractability was even greater. This study suggests that soil extraction methods removing smaller pools of Cu and Zn are more responsive to soil properties affecting chemical lability of the metals. Therefore, chemically nonaggressive neutral salts may be the most appropriate extractants where phytotoxicity is the concern in metal-contaminated soils.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Phytoavailability assessment of heavy metals in soils by single extractions and accumulation by Phaseolus vulgarisEnvironmental and Experimental Botany, 2007
- Evaluation of extractants for estimation of the phytoavailable trace metals in soilsEnvironmental Pollution, 2007
- A test of sequential extractions for determining metal speciation in sewage sludge-amended soilsEnvironmental Pollution, 2006
- TRACE METAL ACCUMULATION BY RED CLOVER GROWN ON SEWAGE SLUDGE-AMENDED SOILS AND CORRELATION TO MEHLICH 3 AND CALCIUM CHLORIDE-EXTRACTABLE METALSSoil Science, 2003
- Cupric Ion Activity in Peat Soil as a Toxicity Indicator for MaizeJournal of Environmental Quality, 2001
- Soil testing for heavy metalsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 2000
- Soil analysis procedures using 0.01 M calcium chloride as extraction reagentCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 2000
- Intérêt de différents réactifs d'extraction chimique pour l'évaluation de la biodisponibilité des métaux en traces du solAgronomy for Sustainable Development, 1996
- Use and Misuse of the DTPA Soil TestJournal of Environmental Quality, 1988
- Development of a DTPA Soil Test for Zinc, Iron, Manganese, and CopperSoil Science Society of America Journal, 1978