Examining the universality of the hemolysis power law model from simulations of the FDA nozzle using calibrated model coefficients
Authors:
- 23 November 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Biomechanics and Modeling in Mechanobiology
- Vol. 22 (2) , 433-451
Abstract
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is widely used to predict mechanical hemolysis in medical devices. The most popular hemolysis model is the stress-based power law model that is based on an empirical correlation between hemoglobin release from red blood cells (RBCs) and the magnitude of flow-induced stress and exposure time. Empirical coefficients are traditionally calibrated using data from experiments in simplified Couette-type blood-shearing devices with uniform-shear laminar flow and well-defined exposure times. Use of such idealized coefficients in simulations of real medical devices with complex hemodynamics is thought to be a primary reason for the historical inaccuracy of absolute hemolysis predictions using the power law model. Craven et al. (Biomech Model Mechanobiol 18:1005–1030, 2019) recently developed a CFD-based Kriging surrogate modeling approach for calibrating empirical coefficients in real devices that could potentially be used to more accurately predict absolute hemolysis. In this study, we use the FDA benchmark nozzle to investigate whether utilizing such calibrated coefficients improves the predictive accuracy of the standard Eulerian power law model. We first demonstrate the credibility of our CFD flow simulations by comparing with particle image velocimetry measurements. We then perform hemolysis simulations and compare the results with in vitro experiments. Importantly, the simulations use coefficients calibrated for the flow of a suspension of bovine RBCs through a small capillary tube, which is relatively comparable to the flow of bovine blood through the FDA nozzle. The results show that the CFD predictions of relative hemolysis in the FDA nozzle are reasonably accurate. The absolute predictions are, however, highly inaccurate with modified index of hemolysis values from CFD in error by roughly three orders of magnitude compared with the experiments, despite using calibrated model coefficients from a relatively similar geometry. We rigorously examine the reasons for the inaccuracy that include differences in the flow conditions in the hemolytic regions of each device and the lack of universality of the hemolysis power law model that is entirely empirical. Thus, while the capability to predict relative hemolysis is valuable for product development, further improvements are needed before the power law model can be relied upon to accurately predict the absolute hemolytic potential of a medical device.Keywords
Funding Information
- Foundation for the National Institutes of Health (HL146921, HL146921)
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Computation of residence time in the simulation of pulsatile ventricular assist devicesComputational Mechanics, 2013
- Results of FDA’s First Interlaboratory Computational Study of a Nozzle with a Sudden Contraction and Conical DiffuserCardiovascular Engineering and Technology, 2013
- A Quantitative Comparison of Mechanical Blood Damage Parameters in Rotary Ventricular Assist Devices: Shear Stress, Exposure Time and Hemolysis IndexJournal of Biomechanical Engineering, 2012
- Evaluation of Eulerian and Lagrangian Models for Hemolysis EstimationASAIO Journal, 2012
- Assessment of CFD Performance in Simulations of an Idealized Medical Device: Results of FDA’s First Computational Interlaboratory StudyCardiovascular Engineering and Technology, 2012
- Study of Flow-Induced Hemolysis Using Novel Couette-Type Blood-Shearing DevicesArtificial Organs, 2011
- Multilaboratory Particle Image Velocimetry Analysis of the FDA Benchmark Nozzle Model to Support Validation of Computational Fluid Dynamics SimulationsJournal of Biomechanical Engineering, 2011
- On the representation of turbulent stresses for computing blood damageInternational Journal of Engineering Science, 2010
- A novel formulation for blood trauma prediction by a modified power-law mathematical modelBiomechanics and Modeling in Mechanobiology, 2005
- Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence models for engineering applicationsAIAA Journal, 1994