Comment on “The hyperpolarizability of trans-butadiene: A critical test case for quantum chemical models” [J. Chem. Phys. 106, 1827 (1997)]
- 8 March 1998
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by AIP Publishing in The Journal of Chemical Physics
- Vol. 108 (10) , 4355-4357
Abstract
It has been suggested that the random phase approximation is superior to many-body/coupled cluster methods for calculating the second hyperpolarizability of trans-butadiene and, by extension, other π-conjugated species. We show that this conclusion is premature because of basis set inadequacies; approximations in the treatment of frequency dispersion; and omission of vibrational effects. We also hypothesize that trans-butadiene may not provide the most critical test of various computational approaches.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Nonlinear optical properties of quasilinear conjugated oligomers, polymers and organic moleculesInternational Reviews in Physical Chemistry, 1997
- A comparative study of the effect of electron correlation in the hyperpolarizability of polyyne, polyacetylene and polypyrrole oligomersChemical Physics Letters, 1995
- Frequency-dependent hyperpolarizabilities in the coupled-cluster method: the Kerr effect for moleculesChemical Physics Letters, 1995
- Calculation of vibrational dynamic hyperpolarizabilities for H2O, CO2, and NH3The Journal of Chemical Physics, 1993
- Linear and nonlinear polarizabilities of t r a n s-polysilane from a b i n i t i o oligomer calculationsThe Journal of Chemical Physics, 1992
- Medium-size polarized basis sets for high-level-correlated calculations of molecular electric propertiesTheoretical Chemistry Accounts, 1991
- Nonlinear-optical susceptibilities of gases measured at 1064 and 1319 nmPhysical Review A, 1990
- Molecular vibrational and rotational motion in static and dynamic electric fieldsReviews of Modern Physics, 1990
- Medium-size polarized basis sets for high-level correlated calculations of molecular electric propertiesCollection of Czechoslovak Chemical Communications, 1988
- Combination of theoretical ab initio and experimental information to obtain reliable harmonic force constants. Scaled quantum mechanical (QM) force fields for glyoxal, acrolein, butadiene, formaldehyde, and ethyleneJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1983