Politically Knowledgeable or Directional (Mis)Believers? How to Identify Those Who Are correct About Political Facts for the “Wrong” Reasons
Open Access
- 26 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Communication Research
Abstract
An informed public is essential to democratic representation, and the news media have traditionally played a central role in supporting this ideal. However, the changing media environment and a rise of misinformation have raised new questions about how citizens acquire and retain political knowledge, prompting distinctions between the uninformed and those holding directional or evidence-resistant misbeliefs. We extend this discussion by arguing that even individuals who are factually accurate may not necessarily be politically knowledgeable, as directional beliefs can sometimes coincide with correct information. We address this both theoretically—by integrating concepts of certainty and attitudes toward evidence—and empirically, by analyzing belief patterns across political issues using Swedish survey data ( N = 2,268). Our findings suggest that individuals can be knowledgeable on some issues yet holding directional (mis)beliefs on others, selectively aligning with facts that support their views. These belief patterns are not associated with traditional news use but correlate with alternative news consumption.Keywords
Funding Information
- Riksbankens Jubileumsfond (M18-0310:1)
This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Structure of Political Choices: Distinguishing Between Constraint and MultidimensionalityPolitical Analysis, 2021
- Belief operationalization for empirical research in psychological sciencesFoundations of Science, 2020
- Reinforcing Spirals Model2020
- Lazy, not biased: Susceptibility to partisan fake news is better explained by lack of reasoning than by motivated reasoningCognition, 2019
- Motivated numeracy and enlightened self-governmentBehavioural Public Policy, 2017
- The Question(s) of Political KnowledgeAmerican Political Science Review, 2014
- How Elite Partisan Polarization Affects Public Opinion FormationAmerican Political Science Review, 2013
- How different are real and hypothetical decisions? Overestimation, contrast and assimilation in social interactionJournal of Economic Psychology, 2012
- Post-Broadcast Democracy2007
- Critique of Pure Reason1998