An archive of contestation: Digital surveillance and human–machine recompositions of resistance
Open Access
- 22 September 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 13 (3)
Abstract
This article proposes to make sense of the ‘atmosphere of failure’ diagnosed by key players in the mobilisation against mass surveillance in the United Kingdom. Firstly, by entangling oral history interviews and computational analyses of NGO websites, we recompose an archive of contestation that is not temporally limited to the Snowden ‘moment’. We advance the notion of a ‘discordant machine’ to render the generativity of discordances and surprises in entangling qualitative and digital methods. Secondly, we argue that the campaigns against surveillance did not lead to a shared vocabulary of critique and a collective practice of contestation. We show that contesting digital state surveillance was mostly expressed through the conduits of privacy and transparency, while more collective democratic claims were connected instead to ‘elsewheres’, such as democratisation in Global South states. Although the Snowden disclosures were a key moment for academic scholarship, our analysis shows that they played little role in mobilisations against mass surveillance. References to oversight were limited to the immediate post-Snowden moment. Finally, corporate surveillance remained a feature of NGO advocacy but was represented mainly at a distance from state surveillance. Our analysis suggests that the challenge for mobilisations against digital surveillance is not only to hold together its complexities but also to articulate its antidemocratic effects.Keywords
Funding Information
- H2020 European Research Council (101141330)
- Economic and Social Research Council (ES/S015132/1)
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Individual Vulnerability and Collective Resistance Under Surveillance: Claiming the Right to Existence against Discriminatory SuspicionInternational Political Sociology, 2024
- Towards democratic intelligence oversight: Limits, practices, strugglesReview of International Studies, 2023
- Compliance-Industrial Complex2022
- Making Digital Surveillance Unacceptable? Security, Democracy, and the Political Sociology of DisputesInternational Political Sociology, 2021
- Designs of borders: Security, critique, and the machinesEuropean Journal of International Security, 2021
- Surveillance under dispute: Conceptualising narrative legitimation politicsEuropean Journal of International Security, 2020
- Latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA) and topic modeling: models, applications, a surveyMultimedia Tools and Applications, 2018
- The Snowden Files Made Public: A Material Politics of Contesting SurveillanceInternational Political Sociology, 2017
- Counter-surveillance as Political Intervention?Social Semiotics, 2006
- The Voice Of The Past2000