A Comprehensive Real-World Evaluation of 5G Improvements Over 4G in Low- and Mid-Bands
- 4 April 2025
- journal article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Cognitive Communications and Networking
- Vol. 11 (3) , 1427-1441
Abstract
With the proliferation of 5G and developments of 6G technologies already underway, understanding the real-world performance of various 5G enhancements such as higher modulation, beamforming, and MIMO of deployed 5G over 4G is vital. This work addresses this knowledge gap by conducting extensive 4G/5G measurements in low- (<1 GHz) and mid-bands (1 to 6 GHz) across Chicago and Minneapolis. As both 4G and 5G utilize low- and mid-band channels, we carefully analyze their performance and signal parameters to reveal several key observations: (i) 5G’s throughput improvement today is mainly driven by wider channel bandwidth in the mid-bands, from both single channels and channel aggregation, (ii) realizing further throughput gains necessitates better signal conditions achievable through denser deployment and/or beamforming, (iii) channel rank analysis shows real-world channel conditions rarely support the full 4×4 MIMO, (iv) advanced features like MU-MIMO and higher order modulation like 1024-QAM have yet to be widely deployed, and (v) aggregated throughput performance in LTE can be enhanced by incorporating shared and unlicensed bands, resulting in a performance similar to single-channel NR. These observations and conclusions suggest that the next generation of cellular systems should prioritize wider channels, possibly with enhanced channel aggregation, and a denser deployment architecture utilizing more beams. This would ensure consistently better signal strength across the coverage area with up to 4 MIMO layers per user.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (CNS-2128489, 2132700, 2220286, 2220292, 2226437, 2229387)
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- A comprehensive analysis of the coverage and performance of 4G and 5G deploymentsComputer Networks, 2023
- Multi-Modal Vehicle Data Delivery via Commercial 5G Mobile Networks: An Initial Study2023
- A Comparative Measurement Study of Commercial 5G mmWave Deployments2022
- A Survey on 5G Radio Access Network Energy Efficiency: Massive MIMO, Lean Carrier Design, Sleep Modes, and Machine LearningIEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, 2022
- Measurement-Based Coexistence Studies of LAA & Wi-Fi Deployments in ChicagoIEEE Wireless Communications, 2020
- A Comprehensive Survey on Millimeter Wave Communications for Fifth-Generation Wireless Networks: Feasibility and ChallengesIEEE Access, 2020
- Beam Management in Millimeter-Wave Communications for 5G and BeyondIEEE Access, 2020
- Massive MIMO and mmWave for 5G Wireless HetNet: Potential Benefits and ChallengesIEEE Vehicular Technology Magazine, 2016
- A Comprehensive Survey of Pilot Contamination in Massive MIMO—5G SystemIEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, 2015
- Pilot Contamination and Precoding in Multi-Cell TDD SystemsIEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications, 2011