Should We Use Carbohydrate-deficient Transferrin instead of γ-Glutamyltransferase for Detecting Problem Drinkers? A Systematic Review and Metaanalysis
Authors:
- Petra MacaskillPMPetra Macaskill
- Les IrwigLILes Irwig
- 1 December 2000
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Clinical Chemistry
- Vol. 46 (12) , 1894-1902
Abstract
Background: Carbohydrate-deficient transferrin (CDT) has been used as a test for excessive alcohol consumption in research, clinical, and medico-legal settings, but there remain conflicting data on its accuracy, with sensitivities ranging from <20% to 100%. We examined evidence of its benefit over a conventional and less expensive test, γ-glutamyltransferase (GGT), and compared the accuracy of different CDT assay methods. Methods: We performed a systematic review using summary ROC analysis of 110 studies prior to June 1998 on the use of CDT in the detection of alcohol dependence or hazardous/harmful alcohol use. Results: We identified several potential sources of bias in studies. In studies examining CDT and GGT in the same subjects, subject characteristics were less likely to influence the comparison. In such paired studies, the original Pharmacia CDT assay was significantly more accurate than GGT, but the modified CDTect assay did not perform as well as the original and was not significantly better than GGT. The accuracy of the AXIS %CDT assay was statistically indistinguishable from modified CDTect. Several CDT assay methods appeared promising, in particular, liquid chromatography (chromatofocusing, HPLC, fast protein liquid chromatography) and isoelectric focusing, but there were insufficient paired studies from which to draw firm conclusions. Conclusions: In studies published before June 1998, the results obtained with commercially available CDT assays were not significantly better than GGT as markers of excessive alcohol use in paired studies. Further high-quality studies comparing CDTect (modified) and other CDT assays with GGT in the same subjects are needed.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Empirical Evidence of Design-Related Bias in Studies of Diagnostic TestsJAMA, 1999
- Analysis of carbohydrate deficient transferrin by capillary zone electrophoresisElectrophoresis, 1997
- Intercurrent complications in chronic alcoholic men admitted to the intensive care unit following traumaIntensive Care Medicine, 1996
- Meta-analytic methods for diagnostic test accuracyJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1995
- Users' Guides to the Medical LiteratureJAMA, 1994
- Users' Guides to the Medical LiteratureJAMA, 1994
- Semi-automatic method for determination of different isoforms of carbohydrate-deficient transferrinClinica Chimica Acta, 1993
- Combining independent studies of a diagnostic test into a summary roc curve: Data‐analytic approaches and some additional considerationsStatistics in Medicine, 1993
- Markers of chronic alcohol ingestion in patients with nonalcoholic steatohepatitis: An aid to diagnosisHepatology, 1991
- Assessing quality of a diagnostic test evaluationJournal of General Internal Medicine, 1989