Estimating the Efficiency of China’s Circular Economy Using an Entropy Approach
- 24 April 2025
- journal article
- Published by World Scientific Pub Co Pte Ltd in Water Economics and Policy
- Vol. 11 (02)
Abstract
The literature predominantly employs traditional data envelopment analysis (DEA) models to measure circular economy efficiency (CEE), overlooking the fact that circular economy systems are complex structures comprised of interconnected subsystems, including production, environmental governance, and circulation processes. Such a conventional approach fails to capture the internal structural dynamics and stage-wise relationships within the system. Therefore, this research uses an improved entropy meta recycle parallel three-stage undesirable slack-based measure (SBM) model and develops a comprehensive indicator system to re-examine CEE of 30 provinces in China from 2016 to 2022. It delves into the stage efficiencies that constrain CEE improvement, including water use efficiency, energy efficiency, environmental governance efficiency, wastewater recycling efficiency, solid waste recycling efficiency and the efficiency of input–output indicators. The findings show that the overall efficiency of China’s circular economy system is relatively low at an average efficiency of only 0.721. All 30 provinces demonstrate varying degrees of potential for improvement in CEE, accompanied by significant regional polarization characteristics. Indeed, 56.6% of the provinces exhibit a fluctuating declining trend in CEE over the sample period. The stage efficiencies that lower CEE vary across provinces, but environmental governance efficiency significantly contributes to overall efficiency in all provinces. Regional disparities in stage efficiency are significant, with the east region maintaining a leading position. Although China has made great efforts in energy conservation and emission reduction, the indicators such as workforce input efficiency in the water and electricity sectors, investment efficiency in water and environmental governance, output efficiency in industrial water reuse, and output efficiency in the integrated utilization of industrial solid waste remain relatively low, resulting in no significant improvement in CEE or efficiency at each stage. The empirical results provide evidence to promote resource conservation and intensive recycling, ensure national resource security, and spur sustainable economic and social development.Keywords
This publication has 90 references indexed in Scilit:
- Two-Stage Evaluation of the Pre-merger Potential Gains of Taiwan Financial Holding Companies: Dynamic Network Slack-Based Measure Analysis ApproachComputational Economics, 2023
- Is Africa's food insecurity linked to land use coverage, irrigation adoption and water scarcity?Irrigation and Drainage, 2023
- A novel integrated fuzzy DEA–artificial intelligence approach for assessing environmental efficiency and predicting CO2 emissionsSoft Computing, 2023
- Impact, adaptation, and mitigation of climate change in Indian agricultureEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2022
- The impact of quality of life on industrial and agricultural production and environmental efficiency in China's provincesManagerial and Decision Economics, 2022
- China’s agricultural ecological efficiency and spatial spillover effectEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2022
- Recycling water and sludge disposal efficiency in China's sewage treatment industryManagerial and Decision Economics, 2021
- Technical Change and Green ProductivityEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2020
- Econometric analysis of industrial water use efficiency in ChinaEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2014
- Metafrontier frameworks for the study of firm-level efficiencies and technology ratiosEmpirical Economics, 2007