Head-to-Head Comparison of Three Methods of Quantifying Competitive Fitness in C. elegans
Preprint
Abstract
Organismal fitness is relevant in many contexts in biology. The most meaningful experimental measure of fitness is competitive fitness, when two or more entities (e.g., genotypes) are allowed to compete directly. In theory, competitive fitness is simple to measure: an experimental population is initiated with the different types in known proportions and allowed to evolve under experimental conditions to a predefined endpoint. In practice, there are several obstacles to obtaining robust estimates of competitive fitness in multicellular organisms, the most pervasive of which is simply the time it takes to count many individuals of different types from many replicate populations. Methods by which counting can be automated in high throughput are desirable, but for automated methods to be useful, the bias and technical variance associated with the method must be (a) known, and (b) sufficiently small relative to other sources of bias and variance to make the effort worthwhile. The nematode Caenorhabditis elegans is an important model organism, and the fitness effects of genotype and environmental conditions are often of interest. We report a comparison of three experimental methods of quantifying competitive fitness, in which wild-type strains are competed against GFP-marked competitors under standard laboratory conditions. Population samples were split into three replicates and counted (1) “by eye” from a saved image, (2) from the same image using CellProfiler image analysis software, and (3) with a large particle flow cytometer (a “worm sorter”). From 720 replicate samples, neither the frequency of wild-type worms nor the among-sample variance differed significantly between the three methods. CellProfiler and the worm sorter provide at least a tenfold increase in sample handling speed with little (if any) bias or increase in variance.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: PLOS ONE, 13 (10), e0201507.
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- The mutational decay of male-male and hermaphrodite-hermaphrodite competitive fitness in the androdioecious nematode C-elegansHeredity, 2018
- An image analysis toolbox for high-throughput C. elegans assaysNature Methods, 2012
- Environmental duress and epistasis: how does stress affect the strength of selection on new mutations?Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 2010
- CellProfiler: image analysis software for identifying and quantifying cell phenotypesGenome Biology, 2006
- A reevaluation of data from competitive tests shows high levels of heterosis in Drosophila melanogaster.Genetics, 1994
- Comparing evolvability and variability of quantitative traits.Genetics, 1992
- On Comparing Coefficients of VariationSystematic Biology, 1977
- Robust Tests for the Equality of VariancesJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1974