Children’s Developmental (Im)maturity: Aligning Conflicting Decisional Capacity Assessment Approaches in Australia
Open Access
Abstract
Children’s decision-making is complex. There are many factors that contribute to children’s decisional capacity including cognitive reasoning, developmental maturity, upbringing and circumstances. For healthcare decisions, Australian law acknowledges children’s autonomy, and permits mature children to consent to beneficial healthcare. Yet, it also protects them from making life-changing decisions that could contravene their best interests. The criminal law approaches to children’s decision-making in Australia’s jurisdictions involves holding older children fully responsible for their decision-making, regardless of circumstances or maturity. The two approaches conflict because health law offers a protective mechanism for children yet criminal law imposes a punitive approach to children’s decision-making. This article considers whether the dichotomous approaches for children’s capacity assessments in Australian law can be reconciled.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Decision-making in the adolescent brainNature Neuroscience, 2012
- Identifying Vulnerable Patients at Heightened Risk for Medical ErrorCritical Care Nurse, 2010
- Trajectories of antisocial behavior and psychosocial maturity from adolescence to young adulthood.Developmental Psychology, 2009
- Adolescent Development and Juvenile JusticeAnnual Review of Clinical Psychology, 2009
- Risk Taking in AdolescenceCurrent Directions in Psychological Science, 2007
- Gillick or Fraser? A plea for consistency over competence in childrenBMJ, 2006
- LABELING, LIFE CHANCES, AND ADULT CRIME: THE DIRECT AND INDIRECT EFFECTS OF OFFICIAL INTERVENTION IN ADOLESCENCE ON CRIME IN EARLY ADULTHOOD*Criminology, 2003
- Abolition of the Presumption of Doli Incapax and the Criminalisation of ChildrenThe Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 1998
- In the Frame: Crime and the Limits of RepresentationAustralian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 1996
- CHILDREN AS PROPERTY?The Modern Law Review, 1988