Organizational Tensions in the Implementation of Modifiable Off-the-Shelf Technologies in a University Hospital: Qualitative Multimethod Study
Authors:
- Alessia NowakANAlessia Nowak
- Carolina GaulCGCarolina Gaul
- Elena HinzEHElena Hinz
- Christine KnollCKChristine Knoll
- Begüm KülBKBegüm Kül
- Anja WelsAWAnja Wels
- Julia C BerkmannJBJulia C Berkmann
- Cathrin de PasqualeCPCathrin de Pasquale
- Gloria KremserGKGloria Kremser
- Daniel FürstenauDFDaniel Fürstenau
- Akira-Sebastian PoncetteAPAkira-Sebastian Poncette
- Felix BalzerFBFelix Balzer
Open Access
- 13 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Human Factors
- Vol. 13, e84841
Abstract
Background: Hospitals face increasing pressure to accelerate digital transformation. Modifiable off-the-shelf technologies (MOTs) combine standardized products with limited adaptability, offering promising opportunities for rapid digitalization. However, implementing MOTs in complex hospital settings involves multiple barriers, facilitators, and organizational dynamics that require deeper investigation. Objective: This study identifies barriers and facilitators in the implementation of MOTs in hospitals and explores how organizational dynamics, conceptualized as tensions, emerge throughout this process. Methods: Guided by a constructivist-interpretivist paradigm, the study followed a collaborative action research approach. A qualitative multimethod design was used, including observations, workshops, and focus groups with clinical and project management staff. Data were analyzed using deductive-inductive qualitative content analysis following Kuckartz’s approach. Results: We analyzed 12 deidentified researcher protocols from 5 observations, 3 workshops, and 4 focus groups. Across these activities, 129 individuals from various wards and departments participated. Barriers and facilitators were clustered into 6 categories representing inhibiting and enabling conditions of MOT implementation. Barriers included product limitations (22.6%, 88/390), misaligned implementation process (4.4%, 17/390), absence of available individuals (3.8%, 15/390), structural challenges (2.8%, 11/390), and resource constraints (2.8%, 11/390). Facilitators included orchestrated implementation process (13.8%, 54/390), product alignment (14.4%, 56/390), effective coordination and communication (9.2%, 36/390), presence of available individuals (6.7%, 26/390), available resources (3.1%, 12/390), and structural assets (1.8%, 7/390). These categories were conceptualized into 3 organizational tensions: limited relative advantage of generic systems, structured participation challenges in complex settings, and constrained engagement despite motivation due to limited resources. Conclusions: Tensions in MOT implementation reflect organizational misfits that go beyond concrete barriers or facilitators and instead require systemic and agile organizational structures. The analysis introduces the concept of user:ability as an organizational capacity for enabling engagement with MOTs. We derive 3 tailored strategies to mitigate the tensions: ensuring relative advantage through IT integration and learning; empowering user participation through digital transformation and communication; and enabling clinician engagement through dedicated resources and systematic implementation. This study advances prior work by deepening the understanding of implementation determinants into organizational tensions and offering actionable strategies to address them. It also illustrates how collaborative, agile research approaches can illuminate complex organizational dynamics and support hospitals during transformative change.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 81 references indexed in Scilit:
- Implementierung von digitalen Technologien in der Patientenversorgung: eine Frage der passenden Strategie(n)2024
- Reimagining Digital HealthBusiness & Information Systems Engineering, 2024
- Digital Therapeutics (DTx)Business & Information Systems Engineering, 2023
- Barriers and facilitators to implementing a nursing clinical decision support system in a tertiary hospital setting: A qualitative study using the FITT frameworkInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2022
- Digital Clinics and Mobile Technology Implementation for Mental Health CareCurrent Psychiatry Reports, 2021
- OpenMRS as a global good: Impact, opportunities, challenges, and lessons learned from fifteen years of implementationInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2021
- Impact of Design on Medical Device SafetyTherapeutic Innovation & Regulatory Science, 2019
- Using Workshops in Business Research: A Framework to Diagnose, Plan, Facilitate and Analyze Workshops2017
- Purposeful Sampling for Qualitative Data Collection and Analysis in Mixed Method Implementation ResearchAdministration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 2013
- Lost in knowledge translation: Time for a map?Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, 2006