One R or the other – an experimental bioethics approach to 3R dilemmas in animal research
Open Access
- 17 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
- Vol. 27 (4) , 497-512
Abstract
Sacrificial dilemmas such as the trolley problem play an important role in experimental philosophy (x-phi). But it is increasingly argued that, since we are not likely to encounter runaway trolleys in our daily life, the usefulness of such thought experiments for understanding moral judgments in more ecologically valid contexts may be limited. However, similar sacrificial dilemmas are experienced in real life by animal research decision makers. As part of their job, they must make decisions about the suffering, and often the death, of many non-human animals. For this reason, a context-specific investigation of so-called “3R dilemmas” (i.e., dilemmas where there is a conflict between the principles of replacement, reduction, and refinement of the use of animals in research) is essential to improve the situation of both non-human animals and human stakeholders. An approach well suited for such investigation is experimental philosophical bioethics (“bioxphi”), which draws on methods similar to x-phi to probe more realistic, practical scenarios with an eye to informing normative debates and ethical policy. In this article, we argue for a need to investigate 3R dilemmas among professional decision-makers using the tools of bioxphi. In a first step, we define 3R dilemmas and discuss previous investigations of professionals’ attitudes in such cases. In a second step, we show how bioxphi is a promising method to investigate the whys and hows of professional decision-making in 3R dilemmas. In a last step, we provide a bioxphi template for 3R dilemmas, give recommendations on its use, explore the normative relevance of data collected by such means, and discuss important limitations.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Basel
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trolleyology2023
- Bioethics, Experimental Approaches2022
- Experimental philosophical bioethics and normative inferenceTheoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2021
- The moral standing of animals: Towards a psychology of speciesism.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2019
- Experimental Neuroethics2019
- Empirical Methods in Animal EthicsJournal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 2015
- Do framing effects make moral intuitions unreliable?Philosophical Psychology, 2014
- Experimenter demand effects in economic experimentsExperimental Economics, 2010
- Accentuate the NegativeReview of Philosophy and Psychology, 2009
- Influence of wording and framing effects on moral intuitionsEthology and Sociobiology, 1996