Automated assessments can support regional Red Lists but need to be applied with caution: A case study from central Germany
Preprint
Abstract
Aim: Expert-based regional Red Lists (RL) carry conservation legislation globally. Yet, they are often difficult to reproduce and their regular compilation by a dwindling number of expert assessors burdens many regional conservation authorities. Here we batch-estimate RL indicators and extinction risk for >1,100 plant species and test the potential of this automated approach to support the expert-based RL process. Location: State of Hesse, Central Germany Methods: First, we estimated current population status, short-term population trend, long-term population trend, and extinction risk by binning existing occurrence probabilities modelled at three time slices with cut-off values derived from RL methodology. Subsequently we compared the results with the latest version of the Hessian expert-based RL using summary statistics and selected example species. Results: We find the assessments of extinction risk to agree in c. 60% of the cases, mostly for species not threatened with extinction. Existing mismatch was by one category in most cases, but up to 6 categories in some cases (mean: 1.6 categories). Furthermore, agreement was highest for extreme categories and very abundant species. Main conclusions: Automated assessments were simplistic for many rare and taxonomically challenging species, but we considered them more accurate than the expert assessments for species with intermediate population size and for species of anthropogenic habitats. Furthermore, the automated assessments are particularly informative for the estimation of long-term and short-term population trends, for which experts are often left to guesstimate based on little data.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Diversity, distribution and preliminary conservation status of the flora of Burkina FasoPhytotaxa, 2017
- The Value of the IUCN Red List for Business Decision‐MakingConservation Letters, 2017
- Rothmaler - Exkursionsflora von Deutschland. Gefäßpflanzen: Grundband2017
- National and subnational Red Lists in European and Mediterranean countries: current state and use for conservationEndangered Species Research, 2016
- Butterfly community shifts over two centuriesConservation Biology, 2016
- Update or Outdate: Long‐Term Viability of the IUCN Red ListConservation Letters, 2013
- Supporting Red List threat assessments with GeoCAT: geospatial conservation assessment toolZooKeys, 2011
- Mapping Species Distributions2010
- Effects of sample size on the performance of species distribution modelsDiversity and Distributions, 2008
- The value of the IUCN Red List for conservationTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2006