Are local-field and local-energy approximations appropriate for modeling nanosecond discharges?
Open Access
- 1 April 2025
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics
- Vol. 58 (18) , 185204
Abstract
A comprehensive solution of the electron kinetics in gas discharges, accounting for dependencies in space, velocity and time, is often unfeasible. Therefore, the electron behavior is frequently coupled to fluid models under one of two assumptions: the local-field approximation (LFA), which equates the electron kinetics to the steady-state calculation with the local and instantaneous value of the reduced electric field; or the local-energy approximation (LEA), in which the rate coefficients and the electron power distribution among different collisional channels depend on the local value of the mean electron energy. In this work, we focus on time-locality to assess the impact of the LFA and LEA assumptions on the calculation of the temporal evolution of the electron kinetics in nanosecond discharges. To do so, we consider an accurate Monte Carlo time-dependent formulation as golden standard. We study electron relaxation in different background gases (air, argon, and mixtures of both) at two pressures (10 and 100 Torr). The LEA generally provides more accurate results than the LFA, with increasing differences at lower pressures, where energy relaxation is slower. The greater accuracy of the LEA comes from the temporal effects introduced by the equation for the mean electron energy, which is absent in the LFA. Opting by the LFA in conditions of slow relaxation can lead to serious degradation of the model results, with errors on the production of excited species up to several tens of percent. Hence, in those scenarios, and when a kinetic approach is not possible, the LEA should be adopted instead of the LFA. The comparison is extended to a two-term time-dependent solver based on a quasi-stationary assumption for the first anisotropy. This method provides a good description of the electron kinetics, except at early times ( ≲ 0.2 ns) at 10 Torr, where the quasi-stationary assumption becomes inaccurate.Keywords
Funding Information
- Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (LA/P/0061/2020)
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- The LisbOn KInetics Monte Carlo solverComputer Physics Communications, 2022
- Experimental and modeling analysis of fast ionization wave discharge propagation in a rectangular geometryPhysics of Plasmas, 2011
- Monte Carlo model for analysis of thermal runaway electrons in streamer tips in transient luminous events and streamer zones of lightning leadersJournal of Geophysical Research, 2006
- The influence of electron–electron collisions on electron thermalization in He and Ar afterglow plasmasChemical Physics Letters, 2003
- Temporal and spatial relaxation of electrons in low temperature plasmasApplied Surface Science, 2002
- Analytical model for the behavior of electric fields in a collisional low-pressure RF dischargeRussian Physics Journal, 1998
- A self-consistent fluid model for radio-frequency discharges in SiH4–H2 compared to experimentsJournal of Applied Physics, 1997
- A comparison of particle in cell and fluid model simulations of low-pressure radio frequency dischargesJournal of Applied Physics, 1994
- Continuum modeling of radio-frequency glow discharges. I. Theory and results for electropositive and electronegative gasesJournal of Applied Physics, 1992
- Analysis of low pressure rf glow discharges using a continuum modelJournal of Applied Physics, 1990