Peer versus Expert Assessment in Academia: Factual and Interpretive Indicators in DigitalTask Performance and Student Reflections
Open Access
- 4 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Technology, Knowledge and Learning
Abstract
Despite many pedagogical benefits, peer assessment is not commonly used due to educators’ concerns about its “objectivity”. This mixed-methods study examines the quality of peer assessment in higher education and contributes to peer-assessment research by distinguishing between factual and interpretive indicators in assessment criteria. Conducted among 168 graduate students in an online course, the study focused on a task requiring students to prepare digital books. These artifacts were assessed by peers and later compared to evaluations by an expert assessor. Students also reflected on the peer-assessment process, providing qualitative insights. The findings revealed differences in assessment quality. For factual indicators, such as completeness of required content, peer assessments tended to be more generous than the expert’s evaluations. However, for interpretive indicators, such as the contribution of the book to the reader’s understanding, peer assessments were generally more critical than the expert assessor. These results suggest that, although peer assessments aligned overall with expert evaluations, reliability varied by the nature of the assessment criteria. Student reflections highlighted significant learning benefits from engaging in peer assessment. Students appreciated constructive feedback from peers, which they described as beneficial for improving their work. Many also reported using the peer-assessment criteria as a framework for analyzing the feedback they received. This internalization of the assessment process underscores the pedagogical value of peer assessment beyond task performance. The findings show that differences between peer and expert evaluations are not uniform but depend on the type of indicator assessed, offering guidance for rubric design and peer-assessment practice.Keywords
Funding Information
- Open University of Israel
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Meta-analyses of Peer Assessment and Affective Outcomes: Motivation, Self-efficacy, and AnxietyEducational Psychology Review, 2026
- A Systematic Review of Peer Assessment Design ElementsEducational Psychology Review, 2023
- Writing private and shared annotations and lurking in Annoto hyper-video in academia: Insights from learning analytics, content analysis, and interviews with lecturers and studentsEducational Technology Research and Development, 2021
- Reflections on the last decade of MOOC researchComputer Applications in Engineering Education, 2020
- Effects of peer assessment within the context of spherical video-based virtual reality on EFL students’ English-Speaking performance and learning perceptionsComputers & Education, 2020
- Does the use of summative peer assessment in collaborative group work inhibit good judgement?Higher Education, 2018
- Re-designed flipped learning model in an academic course: The role of co-creation and co-regulationComputers & Education, 2017
- Digital technologies for promoting “student voice” and co-creating learning experience in an academic courseInstructional Science, 2017
- Enhancing Higher Order Thinking Skills Among Inservice Science Teachers Via Embedded AssessmentJournal of Science Teacher Education, 2009
- Formative assessment and the design of instructional systemsInstructional Science, 1989