Weighing the Harm: Direct Elicitation of Gambling Harm Severity Through Expert Evaluation of Narrative Accounts
Open Access
- 7 August 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Gambling Studies
- p. 1-15
Abstract
This study examined whether direct expert elicitation of gambling harm severity, applied to blinded first-hand narrative accounts, produces ordered and consistent estimates with respect to quantitative self-reports. As such, this represented independent convergent validation evidence of the Gambling Harms Scales (GHS) instruments for people who gamble and affected others (AOs). Six experts with significant research or clinical expertise in the gambling field evaluated 60 transcripts from people who gamble and AOs experiencing varying levels of gambling-related harm (no-harm, low-harm, moderate-harm, and high-harm). Each transcript was evaluated using four protocols (visual analogue scale, rank ordering, time trade-off, and standard gamble). Narratives from participants with higher levels of harm (as assessed by the GHS) were associated with significantly higher expert-elicited health disutility. Disutility increased monotonically with GHS harm bands, and this pattern was consistent across all four elicitation protocols and all six expert raters. Pooled disutility estimates were 0.084 for low-harm, 0.187 for moderate-harm, and 0.221 for high-harm. Harm severity elicited by interviews and expert assessment was consistent with harm severity as assessed by the brief GHS measures. Expert evaluation of blinded narrative accounts provides independent external evidence supporting the GHS suite of instruments as measures of gambling-related harm.Keywords
Funding Information
- Central Queensland University
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Synthesising the available evidence to identify the health impact of gambling harm and gambling problemsAddictive Behaviors, 2026
- The 10-item and 20-item gambling harms scale for affected others (GHS-10-AO, GHS-20-AO): benchmarked to health utility using propensity weighting and control for comorbiditiesAddictive Behaviors, 2025
- Developing a utility value set for the Gambling Quality of Life Scale-Brief (GQoLS-Brief) using a discrete choice experimentQuality of Life Research, 2024
- Gambling-Related Harm to Affected Others: Lived Experience Differs by Relationship Type, Gambling Severity, Life Circumstances, and Relationship FactorsInternational Journal of Mental Health and Addiction, 2024
- Public health approaches to gambling: a global review of legislative trendsThe Lancet Public Health, 2023
- Vignette-Based Utilities: Usefulness, Limitations, and Methodological RecommendationsValue in Health, 2021
- Characterization of the equivalence of robustification and regularization in linear and matrix regressionEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2018
- A tale of two countries: comparing disability weights for gambling problems in New Zealand and AustraliaQuality of Life Research, 2018
- Validation of the Short Gambling Harm Screen (SGHS): A Tool for Assessment of Harms from GamblingJournal of Gambling Studies, 2017
- A comparison of the EQ‐5D and SF‐6D across seven patient groupsHealth Economics, 2004