Bridging complexity through integrative systems neuroscience
Author:
Open Access
- 6 November 2024
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Systems Biology
- Vol. 4, 1487298
Abstract
Neuroscientists have traditionally taken a reductionist approach to understanding the immense complexity of the nervous system. As is the case in other fields of biology, the method of reducing nervous systems into their constitutive parts has proven useful for understanding neural circuits and how they function. As a result, modern neuroscience has thrived on cataloging and scrutinizing individual components of intricate neural systems. Yet, substantial gaps persist in comprehending how these disparate parts coalesce and interact to generate higher-order functions such as behavior, memory, and even consciousness. Bridging these gaps requires a concerted effort to integrate knowledge across subfields in neuroscience, and more broadly, across biology. By taking a systems biology approach to understanding nervous system complexity, we can attempt to build links between molecules, genes, synapses, and behavior.The struggle between understanding individual parts and the whole has been a part of neuroscience since its origin as a scientific discipline. Over a century ago, the field was shaped by the opposing theories of two leading neuroanatomists, Santiago Ramón y Cajal and Camillo Golgi. On the one hand, Golgi's reticular doctrine posited that the nervous system was an interconnected nerve network ("a large syncytium") that was seamless and continuous [Glickstein, 2012] In contrast, Cajal proposed the neuron doctrine which stated that individual nerve cells were the basic structural and functional units of the nervous system [Cajal, 1888]. The structural evidence from the microscopes and stains available to scientists at the time supported Cajal's neuron doctrine. In fact, it was Golgi's "black reaction" (known as a Golgi stain) that produced the most convincing structural evidence that neurons were structurally separated elements [Glickstein 2006]. The introduction of the electron microscope in the 1940s definitively demonstrated that neurons were not continuous but were instead distinct entities separated by synapses with extracellular space in between them. Eventually, Santiago Ramón y Cajal would widely be considered to be the father of modern neuroscience and his neuron doctrine has served as a foundation for the field of neuroscience [Yuste, 2015].Perhaps because of these foundational principles, many of the workhorse techniques and methods of modern neuroscience have thus far been catered to the investigation of individual components that make up neural circuits. For example, Golgi stains and patch-clamp electrophysiological recordings highlight individual neurons. This conceptual focus on individual neurons has obscured, to some extent, our ability to integrate data on how individual function enables higher order processes [Yuste 2015]. As a result, what is missing in the field are general theories of nervous system function that explain how individual neurons contribute to neural circuits that then give rise to behavior, cognition, and other emergent properties of nervous systems. This section of Integrative Systems Neuroscience seeks to address some of these knowledge gaps with multidisciplinary and multiscale analyses of nervous system function.Integrative systems neuroscience is a field that aims to connect disparate components and levels of analyses to gain a better understanding of systems neuroscience. It represents the union of systems biology and neuroscience to integrate results across multiple different levels of analysis and scales, in both the spatial and temporal domains. Using a systems biology approach, we seek to understand complex biological systems by considering them as a whole rather than just the sum of their individual parts. This is accomplished by integrating data from various biological levels and through different analysis approaches to construct comprehensive models or simulations of how different biological components of the nervous system interact.One particular challenge for integrating information in nervous systems is that the constitutive components operate over many orders of magnitude, at least six in the spatial domain [Figure 1] and over nine in the temporal domain (e.g. milliseconds to years). As a result, we are often left with gaps in knowledge between several scales and domains that precludes a more general understanding of function or behavior. The extreme complexity of nervous systems also represents a huge challenge to integrating across levels and scales. In fact, it was the high complexity of nerve tissue that made neural structures so difficult to characterize in the late 1800s, even though the cell theory was already developed and generally accepted for other biological systems.One approach to addressing potential knowledge gaps within a space is to start with the data and go toward abstraction, such that you start from first principles and then you ascend. But oftentimes nervous systems are so complicated and dynamic that this cannot be accomplished in any logical manner. For example, if we have structural biology data that includes angstrom-level resolution to resolve the crystalography of individual proteins (e.g. ion channels), then how can we map this to single neuron structure and function? How do we map that microscopic information to brain-wide circuits? If we instead approach the problem from the top-down (e.g. circuits to proteins), we still encounter large gaps in our understanding before we reach the level of large neural circuits.These knowledge gaps are where a systems biology approach may be able to leverage large amounts of quantitative information to draw insights about neuroscience. As systems biology seeks to understand how biology is organized at multiple levels, this approach can help us make connections between the many levels and types of neuroscientific data.The advent of omics technologies such as genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics (known as the "Big Four"; Dai and Shen,...Keywords
This publication has 76 references indexed in Scilit:
- All-optical physiology resolves a synaptic basis for behavioral timescale plasticityCell, 2023
- The importance of ultrastructural analysis of memoryBrain Research Bulletin, 2021
- The connectome predicts resting-state functional connectivity across the Drosophila brainCurrent Biology, 2021
- The promise and perils of causal circuit manipulationsCurrent Opinion in Neurobiology, 2018
- Targeting Neural CircuitsCell, 2016
- The Enteric Nervous System and Gastrointestinal Innervation: Integrated Local and Central Control2014
- The Molecular and Systems Biology of MemoryCell, 2014
- Neurophysiology of the BOLD fMRI Signal in Awake MonkeysCurrent Biology, 2008
- Integrative neuroscience: linking levels of analysesCurrent Opinion in Neurobiology, 2005
- Systems Theory and Biology—View of a Theoretician1968